Clear-cutting is used by foresters worldwide to harvest timber from forest ecosystems. Clear-cutting of cool–wet boreal forests in late successional stages can maintain successional trajectories pointed toward the composition of a late successional stages. However, clear-cutting of warm–dry boreal forests in late successional stages can trigger reversion of successional trajectories back toward forests of earlier stages because early-successional shade-intolerant species are more abundant than in cool–wet boreal forests, a process that is referred to as a successional setback. Such successional setbacks can generate sustainability issues by extending the expected time to compositional recovery after clear-cutting. This can lead to an overestimation of allowable cuts of economically important late-successional species and subsequently to a temporary forest composition conversion if the occurrence of successional setbacks remains unassessed. Temperate forests in late successional stages are warmer and drier than boreal forests and consequently include more early-successional shade-intolerant species susceptible to encroach clear-cut areas. Even if current ecological knowledge suggests that temperate forests could be susceptible to post-clearcut successional setbacks, a comprehensive assessment has yet to be undertaken. The objective of the present study was to assess whether clear-cutting has triggered successional setbacks in temperate forests. Therefore, we studied post-clearcut successional trajectories by using forest inventory data covering the entire temperate forest of the province of Québec, eastern Canada (209 000 km2). Clear-cutting triggered successional setbacks in both ecological regions forming the temperate forest. After clear-cutting, successional trajectories of trees pointed toward the composition of an early successional stage. To address this sustainable management issue in a comprehensive manner with clear-cutting, foresters could use partial cut approaches.
Read full abstract