Allochthonous Subsidies Research Articles

The role of insectivorous fish in fostering the allochthonous subsidy of lakes

Recently, Wurtsbaugh (2007) commented on our earlier report in which we quantified the nutrient subsidy by a facultative insectivorous fish (bleak, Alburnus alburnus) feeding on terrestrial insects in a 0.12 km2 lake (Groser Vatersee, Germany) (Mehner et al. 2005). We showed that the annual consumption rate of bleak consisted of about 84% terrestrial insects. We estimated that the allochthonous phosphorus included in these insects represented about 2.1% of the lake’s internal total phosphorus (TP) concentration, whereas excretion of P by fish was equivalent to about 11% of the mean epilimnetic soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) concentration. Accordingly, we concluded that the lake studied was only weakly subsidized by allochthonous phosphorus stored in insects. Based on a decay model with varying parameters that calculated the spatial distribution of the daily fallout of terrestrial insects into lakes, we concluded that the subsidy by terrestrial insects to fish consumption and lake nutrient pools was likely most important in small, oligotrophic lakes surrounded by forests. Wurtsbaugh identified three possible shortcomings in our analyses. First, he argues that insects consumed by fish 3 Present address: European Commission, DG Joint Research Centre (JRC), Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen (IPSC), Agriculture and Fisheries Unit, TP 051, I-21020, Ispra, Italy. 2 Present address: Institut fur Systematische Zoologie, Museum fur Naturkunde, Humboldt-Universitat, Invalidenstrase 43, D10115 Berlin, Germany.

ALLOCHTHONOUS SUBSIDY OF PERIODICAL CICADAS AFFECTS THE DYNAMICS AND STABILITY OF POND COMMUNITIES

Periodical cicadas emerge from below ground every 13 or 17 years in North American forests, with individual broods representing the synchronous movement of trillions of individuals across geographic regions. Due to predator satiation, most individuals escape predation, die, and become deposited as detritus. Some of this emergent biomass falls into woodland aquatic habitats (small streams and woodland ponds) and serves as a high-quality allochthonous detritus pulse in early summer. We present results of a two-part study in which we (1) quantified deposition of Brood X periodical cicada detritus into woodland ponds and low-order streams in southwestern Ohio, and (2) conducted an outdoor mesocosm experiment in which we examined the effects of deposition of different amounts of cicada detritus on food webs characteristic of forest ponds. In the mesocosm experiment, we manipulated the amount of cicada detritus input to examine if food web dynamics and stability varied with the magnitude of this allochthonous resource subsidy, as predicted by numerous theoretical models. Deposition data indicate that, during years of periodical cicada emergence, cicada carcasses can represent a sizable pulse of allochthonous detritus to forest aquatic ecosystems. In the mesocosm experiment, cicada carcass deposition rapidly affected food webs, leading to substantial increases in nutrients and organism biomass, with the magnitude of increase dependent upon the amount of cicada detritus. Deposition of cicada detritus impacted the stability of organism functional groups and populations by affecting the temporal variability and biomass minima. However, contrary to theory, stability measures were not consistently related to the size of the allochthonous pulse (i.e., the amount of cicada detritus). Our study underscores the need for theory to further explore consequences of pulsed allochthonous subsidies for food web stability.

Relating body size to the role of aquatic subsidies for the riparian spider Nephila clavata

AbstractWe examined the relationship between body size of the riparian spider Nephila clavata and the contribution of allochthonous (aquatic insects) and autochthonous (terrestrial insects) sources to its diet using stable isotope analysis. During the study period from July to September, the body size of the females increased remarkably (about 60‐fold) but that of males remained small. The biomass of both aquatic and terrestrial insects trapped on the spider webs increased with spider size, with the biomass of the former ranging between 30 and 70% of that of the terrestrial insects. The average relative contribution of aquatic insects to the diet of the spiders, calculated from δ13C values, was 40–50% in spiders in the early juvenile and juvenile stages, 35% in adult males and 4% in adult females. There was a significant negative relationship between the relative contribution of aquatic insects and body size of the female spiders. We conclude that aquatic insects might be an important seasonal dietary subsidy for small spiders and that these allochthonous subsidies may facilitate the growth of riparian spiders, which may in turn enable the spiders to feed on larger prey.

Do seasonally fluctuating aquatic subsidies influence the distribution pattern of birds between riparian and upland forests?

AbstractSeasonal fluctuation of allochthonous subsidies influences food web structure and dynamics in recipient communities. This study investigated whether aquatic subsidies influence the dynamics of insectivorous birds in entire catchment. We estimated the prey biomass and bird density in riparian and upland habitats in three catchments in temperate deciduous forests in Hokkaido, Japan. Aquatic prey was found only in riparian forests and the biomass peaked in early spring, while terrestrial prey was equally distributed between habitats and increased in biomass in late spring. Bird density was higher in riparian than in upland forests before bud break, when the biomass of aquatic insects peaked, but was similar in both forests during the rest of the seasons. These results suggest that aquatic prey subsidies are used not only by birds inhabiting riparian forests, but also by birds associated with upland forests. Aquatic prey subsidies may be particularly important in the spring as a critical food resource for survival and the breeding activities of birds, thereby, influencing the population dynamics of bird communities.

Determination of zooplankton dietary shift following a zebra mussel invasion, as indicated by stable isotope analysis

Summary1. Freshwaters with established zebra mussel populations typically exhibit reduced chlorophyll a concentrations, but the subsequent impacts upon zooplankton are varied. We hypothesised that in an invaded system with less phytoplankton but available allochthonous subsidy, zooplankton may utilise greater proportions of allochthonous matter and that this could be traced by analysis of stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes.2. We used archived zooplankton samples which had been consistently preserved and which spanned the invasion period of an Irish lake, Lough Erne. Increasing reliance upon allochthonous resources would be reflected in an increase in zooplankton δ13C away from phytoplankton which is relatively 13C‐depleted in humic‐stained L. Erne.3. Analysis of a series of monthly samples (1992–96, 1999–2003) revealed significant 13C‐enrichment of mixed zooplankton, Eudiaptomus gracilis and Mysis relicta post‐zebra mussel invasion; δ13C values approached −27‰ typical of terrestrial organic matter during spring and autumn. Changes in zooplankton elemental composition also suggested a switch to a lower quality diet. However, analysis of zooplankton δ13C from an annual, single‐point (June) time series spanning 28 years (1977–2004) suggested that when phytoplankton was sufficiently abundant, zooplankton used this resource and their δ13C remained relatively constant around −32‰. Post‐invasion enrichment of mysid δ15N may reflect a shift towards carnivory, but planktonic prey abundance was reduced and a subsequent loss of body condition could result in the same isotopic changes.4. Our results indicate that in L. Erne, when phytoplankton was reduced by zebra mussel filtering, zooplankton assimilated more from allochthonous matter, and potentially sustained a higher population than would otherwise be possible. Thus, zebra mussel impact on foodweb structure and function is likely to be different in lakes subject to varying subsidy levels.

Nutrient dynamics and ecosystem metabolism in the Bay of Blanes (NW Mediterranean)

The dynamics of the nutrient pools and their stoichiometry as well as their control by ecosystem metabolism (benthic and planktonic) and benthic–pelagic exchanges (sedimentation rates and sediment waterfluxes) were examined in the Mediterranean littoral (Blanes Bay, NE Spain). Dissolved organic nitrogen comprised about half of the nitrogen present in the water column and the carbon pool was dominated by the inorganic pool (95% of the carbon present in the water column). The dissolved and particulate organic pools were deficient in P relative to C and N, indicating a rapid recycling of P from organic matter. The pelagic compartment was heterotrophic, supported by significant allochthonous inputs of land material, which also contributed greatly to the sedimentary inputs (37% of total sedimenting carbon). In contrast, the benthic compartment was autotrophic, with the excess net benthic community production balancing the deficit in pelagic community production, leading to metabolic equilibrium at the station studied. Sedimentary inputs of nitrogen, phosphorus and silicon exceeded the benthic release, indicating that the benthic compartment acted as a sink for nutrients, consistent with its autotrophic nature. Carbon inputs to the benthic compartment also exceeded requirements, due to the allochthonous subsidies to the system, so that the benthic compartment stored or exported organic carbon.

A model of macroinvertebrate trophic structure and oxygen demand in freshwater wetlands

Abstract We present a model of macroinvertebrate trophic structure, detrital cycling, and dissolved oxygen (DO) dynamics in shallow freshwater wetlands with varying allochthonous subsidies. The model is based on field data of primary and secondary production in municipal wastewater-fed and river-fed constructed wetlands in central Ohio, USA. State variables for primary production include macrophyte, periphyton, and metaphyton biomass. Macroinvertebrate biomass is segregated by functional feeding group and includes collectors, scrapers, shredders, and predators. Model simulations demonstrate the association of water column dissolved oxygen, primary production, allochthonous organic matter, and the structure of the macroinvertebrate community. The quality and quantity of allochthonous carbon is shown to have considerable importance, not only as a food source but also as an oxygen sink. Allochthonous carbon equivalent to 5% of autochthonous production increases the macroinvertebrate standing crop by 4–17%, depending on particle size. A large allochthonous subsidy also reduces the simulated average diel dissolved oxygen and increases the percentage of hypoxia-tolerant macroinvertebrates. Simulations show both the heterotrophic response and the changes in community structure brought about by an allochthonous subsidy.