Ecological restoration of arid land plays a pivotal role in maintaining ecological sustainability and enhancing the resilience of local communities. As an ecologically significant arid land, the Qinghai Qaidam Basin has been severely impacted by human activities such as the widespread planting of Lycium chinense, leading to considerable degradation of vegetation and soil carbon and nutrients. Currently, this vital area is undergoing extensive ecological restoration through the employment of a variety of strategies, but the impact remains inadequately understood. This study seeks to compare the effects of different restoration strategies in the Qinghai Qaidam Basin, focusing on soil properties across five scenarios: a controlled desert area, natural restoration after the removal of L. chinense, continued planting of L. chinense, restoration through the planting of Haloxylon ammodendron, and mixed reseeding after four years of restoration. Our findings indicate that mixed reseeding significantly improved soil water storage to 4.26%, especially in the deep soil layer. The planting of H. ammodendron strategy efficiently reduced soil pH in such an alkaline environment. Soil nutrients, including total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), and total potassium (TK), were predominantly concentrated in the top soil layer, with reduced concentrations observed in the medium and deep soil layers. Although soil organic matter remained relatively stable across all restoration strategies, its content was notably lower in the deeper layers. Overall, mixed reseeding proved to be the most efficient strategy for enhancing soil water retention and nutrient levels. In contrast, despite achieving high vegetative coverage to 62.6%, planting of L. chinense was less ecologically beneficial due to its extensive irrigation requirements and adverse effects on soil structure. These findings suggest that restoring degraded areas to an ideal ecological state cannot be achieved within a few years, underscoring the importance of sustained restoration efforts. This study offers valuable insights and practical guidance for the ecological restoration of arid lands, contributing to the development of sustainable land management practices in similar regions.