Philadelphia, Pennsylvania has the highest opioid overdose fatality rate in the United States. The collective progress of combating the opioid crisis in Philadelphia is halted because the tactics imposed, and viewpoints held by numerous public service standpoints have far more differences than similarities. Working together to bridge the gaps between prevention tactics, policies, education, and treatment is imperative for successful mitigation of this ubiquitous problem. Geographic Information Systems (GIS), a mapping software, has made it possible to view comprehensive maps that layer tangible data. This study elucidates risk factors prohibiting Philadelphia from staunching the damage, identifies the impact of prevention strategies, and analyzes treatment success. Open-source data was collected from federal, state, and county health agencies was analyzed using PolicyMap. Individual Pennsylvania (PA) counties’ rate of deaths from all opioid overdoses per 100,000 people in 2019 was assessed in relation to the national rate (15) and the PA rate (23). areas with rates less than 20 were shown as “insufficient data.” County rates of opioid prescriptions per 100 people were compared with the national rate (46.7) and PA rate (47). The reported Index of Medical Underservice Score (IMU) data for only Philadelphia was visualized by census tract with the upper limit adjusted to 62, to reflect the US Health Resources and Services Administration definition of a Medically Underserved Area (MUA). Non-MUA and Governor are shown as “insufficient data.” Buprenorphine providers, drug and alcohol treatment facilities, and hospitals were plotted on the IMU and poverty maps. The Philadelphia estimated percent of people living in poverty between 2015-2019 was mapped using ranges based on census tracts. These ranges were compared to the whole number national poverty average (13) and average for Pennsylvania (12). Philadelphia’s rate of deaths from opioid overdose per 100,000 people in 2019 is 50.4, two times the PA average and over three times the national average. It is the only PA county with an opioid rate over 50. The rate of opioid prescriptions per 100 people in 2019 is 49.9, similar to the national rate (46.7) and the PA rate (47). Treatment resources, 428 buprenorphine prescribers, 84 drug and alcohol treatment facilities, and 33 hospitals, were spread out unequally within Philadelphia. Central, East, and Southwest regions of Philadelphia are MUAs with a moderate concentration of buprenorphine prescribers and alcohol and drug treatment facilities. Hospitals were sparse in regions with very low IMU scores and consolidated in Central Philadelphia. Poverty rates varied throughout Philadelphia with a notable absence in hospitals in the areas with highest percentages of poverty. GIS provides dynamic public health measures that underscore critical data and correlate terrain with strategic outcomes. This comparative data tool was utilized to both highlight the detrimental impact of the opioid crisis in Philadelphia and evaluate the inadequate deployment of various prevention and treatment tactics. The evidence that this region is prescribing opioids at slightly above the state and national averages while simultaneously having much more fatal opioid overdoses, highlights the need for new harm reduction strategies to reverse the pernicious trends that have devastated Philadelphia.
Read full abstract