After a structural-related composite aircraft crash, a fractographic forensic analysis of the damaged surfaces is typically performed to assess the root causes of mechanical failures. Such accident reconstruction efforts, however, can be impeded if the aircraft catches on fire on the ground (i.e., a post-crash fire occurs), where flames or heat exposure can obscure or destroy the fracture surface morphologies of the fibers (i.e., the primary load carrying constituent). In this study, carbon/epoxy Pultruded Rod Stitched Efficient Unitized Structure (PRSEUS) skin-stringer assemblies were subjected to uniaxial compression and subsequently exposed to direct flame using a Bunsen burner. Specimens were oriented parallel, orthogonal, and at 45° to the flame axis for durations of 60 s. Additional vertical burn tests were performed for durations up to 300 s. Fractographic inspection of the failure surfaces before and after flame exposure was performed using a combination of destructive sectioning and scanning electron microscopy. The warp-knitted skin (fascia) surrounding the pultruded rod effectively served as a thermal protection layer, which shielded the rod’s broken filaments from significant thermal degradation and facilitated the identification of microbuckling and other mechanical failure mechanisms. This suggests that the presence of fascia, bulkheads, ribs, skins, and other intermediate layers in aircraft structures may significantly shield underlying principal structural element failure surfaces from fire exposure, facilitating post-crash forensic assessments of composite aircraft. Additionally, the through-thickness VectranTM stitching remained intact even after extended flame exposure, suggesting that such stitching can enhance the fire resistance of composite structures.