The immiscibility of crystallographic facets in multi-metallic catalysts plays a key role in driving the green H2 production by water electrolysis. The lattice mismatch between tetragonal In and face-centered cubic (fcc) Ni is 14.9 % but the mismatch with hexagonal close-packed (hcp) Ni is 49.8 %. Hence, in a series of Ni-In heterogeneous alloys, In is selectively incorporated in the fcc Ni. The 18-20 nm Ni particles have 36 wt % fcc phase, which increases to 86 % after In incorporation. The charge transfer from In to Ni, stabilizes the Ni0 state and In develops a fractional positive charge that favors *OH adsorption. With only 5 at% In, 153 mL h-1 H2 is evolved at -385 mV with mass activity of 57.5 A g-1 at-400 mV, 200 h stability at -0.18 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), and Pt-like activity at high current densities, due to the spontaneous water dissociation, lower activation energy barrier, optimal adsorption energy of OH- ions and the prevention of catalyst poisoning.