Adrenal hemorrhage is a rare, but important, diagnosis to recognize, in particular when there is involvement of both adrenal glands. Bilateral adrenal hemorrhage can in fact lead to adrenal insufficiency, with dramatic consequences if not promptly recognized and treated. It is normally caused by systemic conditions that lead to the vasoconstriction and thrombosis of the adrenal vein. Oftentimes, the clinical diagnosis of this condition can be very challenging, as its signs and symptoms are generalized and nonspecific (abdominal pain, nausea, and fatigue). Here, we present the cases of two patients admitted to the Emergency Department in 2016 and 2022 with acute abdominal pain, having recently undergone surgery and subsequently prescribed low-molecular-weight heparin. In both cases, laboratory results revealed neutrophilic leukocytosis and an unexplained anemia. Due to the persistence of abdominal pain despite medication, a CT scan was performed, showing an enlargement of both adrenal glands suggestive of bilateral adrenal hemorrhage. Adrenal function was tested that correlated with a diagnosis of adrenal insufficiency, and both patients were promptly treated with parenteral hydrocortisone as a result. On 5 years' follow-up from the acute event, the second patient's adrenal function had returned to normal, and he has not needed further adrenal replacement therapy; the first patient however demonstrated persistence of adrenal failure requiring replacement therapy. In this paper, through our experience and a literature analysis, we will aim to outline some clues to identify patients at potential risk of bilateral adrenal hemorrhage.