Nickel gaskets for large-bored vacuum flange systems remain virtually nonexistent in practical use, despite strong demand for a gasket invulnerable to both oxidation and reduction atmospheres in vacuum application processes. Nickel gaskets would seem preferable in these processes, which are characterized by sensitivity to copper contamination and in which highly corrosive gases could wear away copper gaskets. In working to develop a nickel gasket for the ConFlat-type sealing system with a seal reliability and handling impression comparable to conventional copper gaskets, the authors found that nickel-plated copper gaskets could not attain secure sealing because the nickel layer was too hard to form a tight fit with the flange face. In earlier developmental stages, seven types of prototype nickel gaskets were produced and subjected to a tightening test. These prototype gaskets varied in their respective annealings and/or applied surface finishes. In the tightening test, deep penetration of the flange knife edge and a wide seal area were obtained on all the annealed prototypes, but their seal ability was nevertheless inferior to copper gaskets, even in the best case. Traced surface profiles of the tightened prototype gaskets with relatively roughly finished surfaces revealed that the original outlines of many protuberances and dimples remained, even after considerable seal pressure was applied on them. This observation suggests that the actual contact area between the gasket face and flange face was narrower than the apparent seal area, and too small to achieve secure sealing. Such poor accommodation of the flange surface was rarely observed on tightened gaskets with smoothly finished surfaces, although fine scratches remaining on the surface frequently functioned as leak paths after the tightening was completed. This insufficient fine deformation ability of the surface was not observed in commercially available copper gaskets. Results of tensile tests on prototype nickel gaskets versus commercially available copper gaskets made it clear that undesirable stiffness is an intrinsic characteristic of nickel gasket surfaces. This arises from the high hardening rate of the nickel material, and therefore cannot be improved by annealing alone. On further evaluation of the prototypes, the authors concluded that three factors are indispensable in order for nickel gaskets to be put into practical use: annealing to reduce hardness, a proper surface finish to obtain a tight fit on the sealing interface, and some sort of protection against scratching the gasket surface. This last requirement can be met by machining to reduce the sealing face region of the gasket surface. The final prototype nickel gasket, a concave version annealed and finished with fine lathing, showed basic sealing and flange knife edge damage characteristics comparable to copper gaskets, with superior seal stability at elevated temperature.