Spindle Assembly Checkpoint Activation Research Articles

Mitosis inhibitors in anticancer therapy: When blocking the exit becomes a solution

Current microtubule-targeting agents (MTAs) remain amongst the most important antimitotic drugs used against a broad range of malignancies. By perturbing spindle assembly, MTAs activate the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC), which induces mitotic arrest and subsequent apoptosis. However, besides toxic side effects and resistance, mitotic slippage and failure in triggering apoptosis in various cancer cells are limiting factors of MTAs efficacy. Alternative strategies to target mitosis without affecting microtubules have, thus, led to the identification of small molecules, such as those that target spindle Kinesins, Aurora and Polo-like kinases. Unfortunately, these so-called second-generation of antimitotics, encompassing mitotic blockers and mitotic drivers, have failed in clinical trials. Our recent understanding regarding the mechanisms of cell death during a mitotic arrest pointed out apoptosis as the main variable, providing an opportunity to control the cell fates and influence the effectiveness of antimitotics. Here, we provide an overview on the second-generation of antimitotics, and discuss possible strategies that exploit SAC activity, mitotic slippage/exit and apoptosis induction, in order to improve the efficacy of anticancer strategies that target mitosis.

Loss of Kif18A Results in Spindle Assembly Checkpoint Activation at Microtubule-Attached Kinetochores

The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) halts anaphase progression until all kinetochores have obtained bipolar, stable attachments to the mitotic spindle. Upon initial attachment, chromosomes undergo oscillatory movements to reach metaphase. Once a chromosome is correctly attached and positioned, these oscillatory movements are reduced by the motor protein Kif18A, and loss of Kif18A results in chromosome hyper-oscillations. By using a haploid genetic approach, we found that loss of Kif18A is lethal in wild-type human HAP1 cells, but not in SAC-deficient HAP1 cells. Unexpectedly, we found that the hyper-oscillations after Kif18A loss are not associated with chromosome missegregations. Rather, we found that loss of Kif18A results in a loss of tension across a subset of kinetochores accompanying SAC activation. Strikingly, the SAC-active kinetochores appear to have established fully functional kinetochore-microtubule (k-Mt) attachments, allowing proper chromosome segregation. These findings shed new light on the role of Kif18A in chromosome segregation and demonstrate that the SAC can be activated at kinetochores that are occupied by fully functional k-Mts that lack tension.

Histone methyltransferase SETD2 is required for meiotic maturation in mouse oocyte.

SET-domain-containing 2 (SETD2), a member of the histone lysine methyltransferase family, has been reported to be involved in multiple biological processes. However, the function of SETD2 during oocyte maturation has not been addressed. In this study, we find that mouse oocytes are incapable of progressing through meiosis completely once SETD2 is specifically depleted. These oocytes present an abnormal spindle morphology and deficient chromosome movement, with disrupted kinetochore-microtubule attachments, consequently producing aneuploidy eggs. In line with this, the BubR1 signal is markedly elevated in metaphase kinetochores of oocytes with SETD2 depletion, indicative of the activation of spindle assembly checkpoint. In addition, we note that loss of SETD2 results in a drastic decrease in the trimethylation level of H3K36 in oocytes. Collectively, our data demonstrate that SETD2 is required for oocyte maturation and indicate a novel mechanism controlling the meiotic apparatus.

Chromosomes trapped in micronuclei are liable to segregation errors.

ABSTRACTDNA in micronuclei is likely to get damaged. When shattered DNA from micronuclei gets reincorporated into the primary nucleus, aberrant rearrangements can take place, a phenomenon referred to as chromothripsis. Here, we investigated how chromatids from micronuclei act in subsequent divisions and how this affects their fate. We observed that the majority of chromatids derived from micronuclei fail to establish a proper kinetochore in mitosis, which is associated with problems in chromosome alignment, segregation and spindle assembly checkpoint activation. Remarkably, we found that, upon their formation, micronuclei already display decreased levels of important kinetochore assembly factors. Importantly, these defects favour the exclusion of the micronucleus over the reintegration into the primary nucleus over several divisions. Interestingly, the defects observed in micronuclei are likely overcome once micronuclei are reincorporated into the primary nuclei, as they further propagate normally. We conclude that the formation of a separate small nuclear entity represents a mechanism for the cell to delay the stable propagation of excess chromosome(s) and/or damaged DNA, by inducing kinetochore defects.

Role of Kip2 during early mitosis - impact on spindle pole body separation and chromosome capture.

Mitotic spindle dynamics are regulated during the cell cycle by microtubule motor proteins. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, one such protein is Kip2p, a plus-end motor that regulates the polymerization and stability of cytoplasmic microtubules (cMTs). Kip2p levels are regulated during the cell cycle, and its overexpression leads to the formation of hyper-elongated cMTs. To investigate the significance of varying Kip2p levels during the cell cycle and the hyper-elongated cMTs, we overexpressed KIP2 in the G1 phase and examined the effects on the separation of spindle pole bodies (SPBs) and chromosome segregation. Our results show that failure to regulate the cMT lengths during G1-S phase prevents the separation of SPBs. This, in turn, affects chromosome capture and leads to the activation of spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) and causes mitotic arrest. These defects could be rescued by either the inactivation of checkpoint components or by co-overexpression of CIN8, which encodes a motor protein that elongates inter-polar microtubules (ipMTs). Hence, we propose that the maintenance of Kip2p level and cMT lengths during early cell division is important to ensure coordination between SPB separation and chromosome capture by kinetochore microtubules (kMTs).

The effect and mechanism of millepachine-disrupted spindle assembly in tumor cells.

Millepachine (MIL) is a bioactive natural product that shows great potential for cancer treatment. Previous studies showed that MIL was a novel cancer drug candidate with a special structure. To provide reference for the research and development of MIL, we further investigated the mechanism of MIL inducing G2/M arrest and found MIL disrupted spindle assembly in tumor cells. In this study, we investigated the disrupting spindle assembly effects of MIL with a focus on its potential mechanism of action. First, we indicated that MIL did not inhibit microtubule polymerization from the results of in-vivo microtubule nucleation assay and microtubule polymerization in-vitro assay but delayed this process by inhibiting the production of ATP in tumor cells. Thereafter, we investigated the effect of MIL on the mitotic spindle. We found that MIL induced multipolar spindles by inhibiting the activity of Eg5 and inhibited mitotic spindle formation and chromatin condensation by the activation of the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) in tumor cells. These results established a novel function of MIL in regulating the assembly of mitotic spindle. As Eg5 and SAC are antitumor targets, effect of MIL on the Eg5 protein and SAC activation hinted that MIL has novel application in the development of antitumor drugs.

The closed form of Mad2 is bound to Mad1 and Cdc20 at unattached kinetochores

ABSTRACTThe spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) ensures accurate chromosome segregation by delaying anaphase onset in response to unattached kinetochores. Anaphase is delayed by the generation of the mitotic checkpoint complex (MCC) composed of the checkpoint proteins Mad2 and BubR1/Bub3 bound to the protein Cdc20. Current models assume that MCC production is catalyzed at unattached kinetochores and that the Mad1/Mad2 complex is instrumental in the conversion of Mad2 from an open form (O-Mad2) to a closed form (C-Mad2) that can bind to Cdc20. Importantly the levels of Mad2 at kinetochores correlate with SAC activity but whether C-Mad2 at kinetochores exclusively represents its complex with Mad1 is not fully established. Here we use a recently established C-Mad2 specific monoclonal antibody to show that Cdc20 and C-Mad2 levels correlate at kinetochores and that depletion of Cdc20 reduces Mad2 but not Mad1 kinetochore levels. Importantly reintroducing wild type Cdc20 but not Cdc20 R132A, a mutant form that cannot bind Mad2, restores Mad2 levels. In agreement with this live cell imaging of fluorescent tagged Mad2 reveals that Cdc20 depletion strongly reduces Mad2 localization to kinetochores. These results support the presence of Mad2-Cdc20 complexes at kinetochores in agreement with current models of the SAC but also argue that Mad2 levels at kinetochores cannot be used as a direct readout of Mad1 levels.

Spindle assembly checkpoint strength is linked to cell fate in the Caenorhabditis elegans embryo.

The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) is a conserved mitotic regulator that preserves genome stability by monitoring kinetochore–microtubule attachments and blocking anaphase onset until chromosome biorientation is achieved. Despite its central role in maintaining mitotic fidelity, the ability of the SAC to delay mitotic exit in the presence of kinetochore–microtubule attachment defects (SAC “strength”) appears to vary widely. How different cellular aspects drive this variation remains largely unknown. Here we show that SAC strength is correlated with cell fate during development of Caenorhabditis elegans embryos, with germline-fated cells experiencing longer mitotic delays upon spindle perturbation than somatic cells. These differences are entirely dependent on an intact checkpoint and only partially attributable to differences in cell size. In two-cell embryos, cell size accounts for half of the difference in SAC strength between the larger somatic AB and the smaller germline P1 blastomeres. The remaining difference requires asymmetric cytoplasmic partitioning downstream of PAR polarity proteins, suggesting that checkpoint-regulating factors are distributed asymmetrically during early germ cell divisions. Our results indicate that SAC activity is linked to cell fate and reveal a hitherto unknown interaction between asymmetric cell division and the SAC.

Antagonism between the dynein and Ndc80 complexes at kinetochores controls the stability of kinetochore–microtubule attachments during mitosis

Chromosome alignment and segregation during mitosis require kinetochore-microtubule (kMT) attachments that are mediated by the molecular motor dynein and the kMT-binding complex Ndc80. The Rod-ZW10-Zwilch (RZZ) complex is central to this coordination as it has an important role in dynein recruitment and has recently been reported to have a key function in the regulation of stable kMT attachments in Caenorhabditis elegans besides its role in activating the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC). However, the mechanism by which these protein complexes control kMT attachments to drive chromosome motility during early mitosis is still unclear. Here, using in vitro total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy, we observed that higher concentrations of Ndc80 inhibited dynein binding to MTs, providing evidence that Ndc80 and dynein antagonize each other's function. High-resolution microscopy and siRNA-mediated functional disruption revealed that severe defects in chromosome alignment induced by depletion of dynein or the dynein adapter Spindly are rescued by codepletion of the RZZ component Rod in human cells. Interestingly, rescue of the chromosome alignment defects was independent of Rod function in SAC activation and was accompanied by a remarkable restoration of stable kMT attachments. Furthermore, the chromosome alignment rescue depended on the plus-end-directed motility of centromere protein E (CENP-E) because cells codepleted of CENP-E, Rod, and dynein could not establish stable kMT attachments or align their chromosomes properly. Our findings support the idea that dynein may control the function of the Ndc80 complex in stabilizing kMT attachments directly by interfering with Ndc80-MT binding or indirectly by controlling the Rod-mediated inhibition of Ndc80.

First person – Thibault Courtheoux and Alghassimou Diallo

ABSTRACT First Person is a series of interviews with the first authors of a selection of papers published in Journal of Cell Science, helping early-career researchers promote themselves alongside their papers. Thibault Courtheoux and Alghassimou Diallo are joint first authors on ‘Aurora A kinase activity is required to maintain an active spindle assembly checkpoint during pro-metaphase’, published in Journal of Cell Science. Thibault is a postdoc and Alghassimou a PhD student in the lab of Dr Claude Prigent at IGDR-UMR, Université de Rennes, France, investigating cell division and mechanisms leading to chromosome instability and cancer.

The cohesion establishment factor Esco1 acetylates α-tubulin to ensure proper spindle assembly in oocyte meiosis.

Esco1 has been reported to function as a cohesion establishment factor that mediates chromosome cohesion and segregation in mitotic cells. However, its exact roles in meiosis have not been clearly defined. Here, we document that Esco1 is expressed and localized to both the nucleus and cytoplasm during mouse oocyte meiotic maturation. Depletion of Esco1 by siRNA microinjection causes the meiotic progression arrest with a severe spindle abnormality and chromosome misalignment, which is coupled with a higher incidence of the erroneous kinetochore–microtubule attachments and activation of spindle assembly checkpoint. In addition, depletion of Esco1 leads to the impaired microtubule stability shown by the weakened resistance ability to the microtubule depolymerizing drug nocodazole and the decreased level of acetylated α-tubulin. Conversely, overexpression of Esco1 causes hyperacetylation of α-tubulin and spindle defects. Moreover, we find that Esco1 binds to α-tubulin and is required for its acetylation. The reduced acetylation level of α-tubulin in Esco1-depleted oocytes can be restored by the ectopic expression of exogenous wild-type Esco1 but not enzymatically dead Esco1-G768D. Purified wild-type Esco1 instead of mutant Esco1-G768D acetylates the synthesized peptide of α-tubulin in vitro. Collectively, our data assign a novel function to Esco1 as a microtubule regulator during oocyte meiotic maturation beyond its conventional role in chromosome cohesion.

Loss of Kif18A Results in Spindle Assembly Checkpoint Activation at Microtubule-attached Kinetochores

The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) halts anaphase progression until all kinetochores have obtained bipolar, stable attachments to the mitotic spindle. Upon initial attachment, chromosomes undergo oscillatory movements to reach metaphase. Once a chromosome is correctly attached and positioned, these oscillatory movements are reduced by the motor protein Kif18A, and loss of Kif18A is associated with chromosome hyper-oscillations. By using a haploid genetic approach, we found that loss of Kif18A is lethal in wild-type human HAP1 cells but not in SAC-deficient HAP1 cells. We found that the hyper-oscillations are associated with a loss of tension across kinetochores and SAC-activation but, unexpectedly, not with chromosome missegregations. Strikingly, the SAC-active kinetochores appear to have established fully functional kinetochoremicrotubule (k-Mt) attachments, allowing proper chromosome segregation. These findings shed new light on the role of Kif18A in chromosomal stability and demonstrate that the SAC can be activated by kinetochores that are occupied by fully functional k-Mts that lack tension.

Tension-Induced Error Correction and Not Kinetochore Attachment Status Activates the SAC in an Aurora-B/C-Dependent Manner in Oocytes

Cell division with partitioning of the genetic material should take place only when paired chromosomes named bivalents (meiosis I) or sister chromatids (mitosis and meiosis II) are correctly attached to the bipolar spindle in a tension-generating manner. For this to happen, the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) checks whether unattached kinetochores are present, in which case anaphase onset is delayed to permit further establishment of attachments. Additionally, microtubules are stabilized when they are attached and under tension. In mitosis, attachments not under tension activate the so-named error correction pathway depending on Aurora B kinase substrate phosphorylation. This leads to microtubule detachments, which in turn activates the SAC [1-3]. Meiotic divisions in mammalian oocytes are highly error prone, with severe consequences for fertility and health of the offspring [4, 5]. Correct attachment of chromosomes in meiosis I leads to the generation of stretched bivalents, but-unlike mitosis-not to tension between sister kinetochores, which co-orient. Here, we set out to address whether reduction of tension applied by the spindle on bioriented bivalents activates error correction and, as a consequence, the SAC. Treatment of oocytes in late prometaphase I with Eg5 kinesin inhibitor affects spindle tension, but not attachments, as we show here using an optimized protocol for confocal imaging. After Eg5 inhibition, bivalents are correctly aligned but less stretched, and as a result, Aurora-B/C-dependent error correction with microtubule detachment takes place. This loss of attachments leads to SAC activation. Crucially, SAC activation itself does not require Aurora B/C kinase activity in oocytes.

Hydrogen Peroxide Prolongs Mitotic Arrest in a Dose Dependent Manner and Independently of the Spindle Assembly Checkpoint Activity in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Oxidative stress and chromosome missegregation are important factors that are linked to aneuploidy. A major reason for chromosome missegragation is the inappropriate activity of the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC), a conserved surveillance mechanism that monitors the state of kinetochore-microtubule attachments to ensure equal chromosome segregation in mitosis. SAC-activation induces a prolonged mitotic arrest. Mitosis is considered the most vulnerable cell cycle phase to several external signals, therefore increasing the time cells spent in this phase via mitotic arrest induction by SAC-activating agents is favorable for cancer therapy. Cancer cells also display elevated oxidative stress due to abnormally high production of reactive oxygen species (ROS). However, the effect of increased oxidative stress on the duration of mitotic arrest remains largely unknown. In this study, we investigated the effect of H2O2-induced oxidative stress on the mitotic arrest induced by a SAC-activating agent (nocodazole) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Our data suggest that oxidative stress prolongs SAC-activation induced mitotic arrest in a dose dependent manner. We, in addition, investigated the effect of H2O2 treatment on the mitotic arrest induced independently of SAC-activation by using a conditional mutant (cdc23) and showed that the effect of H2O2-induced oxidative stress on mitotic arrest is independent of the SAC activity.

Folate deficiency induces mitotic aberrations and chromosomal instability by compromising the spindle assembly checkpoint in cultured human colon cells

Folates comprise the essential B9 vitamin that act as cofactors and cosubstrates in one-carbon metabolism for both biosynthesis and methylation of DNA and RNA. Folate deficiency (FD) has been shown to induce chromosomal instability (CIN), yet the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we used human NCM460 colon mucosal cells as a model to investigate the effect of FD on spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC), a cell-cycle regulatory pathway preventing CIN during mitosis. Cells were maintained in medium containing 1.36 (FD) and 2260 nM (control, FC) folate for 21 days. CIN was measured by cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay; mitotic infidelity was determined by aberrant mitosis analysis; SAC activity was assessed by nocodazole-challenge assay, and the expression of core SAC genes was examined by real-time quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR). We found that, relative to FC, FD significantly induced CIN in a time-dependent way (P < 0.01). Mitotic cells cultured in FD medium had significant higher frequencies of misalignment, misegregation and spindle multipolarity than those cultured in FC medium (P < 0.01). FD-induced SAC impairment and overriding, resulting premature mitotic exit and cell multinucleation (P < 0.05). Moreover, FD deregulated the expression of several key SAC genes (P < 0.01). Overall, these data are the first to demonstrate that FD substantially compromises SAC network which predisposes cells to mitotic aberrations and CIN. These results establish a new link between folate metabolism and SAC signalling, two pathways that are highly relevant for tumorigenesis.

Biphasic regulation of spindle assembly checkpoint by low and high concentrations of resveratrol leads to the opposite effect on chromosomal instability

Resveratrol (RSV) is a naturally occurring polyphenolic phytoalexin possessing numerous health-promoting effects. Chromosomal instability (CIN), usually results from defective spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC), is a major contributor to many diseases. While it’s recently recognized that RSV exhibits a nonlinear dose response for disease prevention, whether it’s the case for its role in CIN remains unknown. Here, we investigated the potential of a broad range of RSV concentrations (0.01–100μM) on CIN and the underlying mechanisms in human normal colon epithelial NCM460 cells. CIN was measured by cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay; mitotic fidelity was determined by aberrant mitosis analysis; SAC activity was assessed by nocodazole-challenge assay, and the expression of SAC genes was examined by RT-qPCR. We found that 0.1μM RSV significantly reduced CIN (P<0.01), while 100μM RSV significantly induced it (P<0.05). Mitotic infidelity was significantly prevented by 0.1μM RSV but promoted by 100μM RSV (P<0.05 for both). Moreover, the function of SAC was sustained and impaired by 0.1μM and 100μM RSV, respectively. Several SAC genes, including Aurora-B, Aurora-C, Plk-1 and CENP-E, were significantly up-regulated and down-regulated by 0.1μM and 100μM RSV, respectively (P<0.05). In conclusion, RSV exhibited a biphasic dose-dependent effect on CIN that was exerted via the regulation of mitotic fidelity through the SAC network. The health implications of these findings were summarized.

An Attachment-Independent Biochemical Timer of the Spindle Assembly Checkpoint

The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) generates a diffusible protein complex that prevents anaphase until all chromosomes are properly attached to spindle microtubules. A key step in SAC initiation is the recruitment of MAD1 to kinetochores, which is generally thought to be governed by the microtubule-kinetochore (MT-KT) attachment status. However, we demonstrate that the recruitment of MAD1 via BUB1, a conserved kinetochore receptor, is not affected by MT-KT interactions in human cells. Instead, BUB1:MAD1 interaction depends on BUB1 phosphorylation, which is controlled by a biochemical timer that integrates counteracting kinase and phosphatase effects on BUB1 into a pulse-generating incoherent feedforward loop. We propose that this attachment-independent timer serves to rapidly activate the SAC at mitotic entry, before the attachment-sensing MAD1 receptors have become fully operational. The BUB1-centered timer is largely impervious to conventional anti-mitotic drugs, and it is, therefore, a promising therapeutic target to induce cell death through permanent SAC activation.

Rad52 phosphorylation by Ipl1 and Mps1 contributes to Mps1 kinetochore localization and spindle assembly checkpoint regulation

Rad52 is well known as a key factor in homologous recombination. Here, we report that Rad52 has functions unrelated to homologous recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae; it plays a role in the recruitment of Mps1 to the kinetochores and the maintenance of spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) activity. Deletion of RAD52 causes various phenotypes related to the dysregulation of chromosome biorientation. Rad52 directly affects efficient operation of the SAC and accurate chromosome segregation. Remarkably, by using an in vitro kinase assay, we found that Rad52 is a substrate of Ipl1/Aurora and Mps1 in yeast and humans. Ipl1-dependent phosphorylation of Rad52 facilitates the kinetochore accumulation of Mps1, and Mps1-dependent phosphorylation of Rad52 is important for the accurate regulation of the SAC under spindle damage conditions. Taken together, our data provide detailed insights into the regulatory mechanism of chromosome biorientation by mitotic kinases.

The fission yeast nucleoporin Alm1 is required for proteasomal degradation of kinetochore components.

Kinetochores (KTs) are large multiprotein complexes that constitute the interface between centromeric chromatin and the mitotic spindle during chromosome segregation. In spite of their essential role, little is known about how centromeres and KTs are assembled and how their precise stoichiometry is regulated. In this study, we show that the nuclear pore basket component Alm1 is required to maintain both the proteasome and its anchor, Cut8, at the nuclear envelope, which in turn regulates proteostasis of certain inner KT components. Consistently, alm1-deleted cells show increased levels of KT proteins, including CENP-CCnp3, spindle assembly checkpoint activation, and chromosome segregation defects. Our data demonstrate a novel function of the nucleoporin Alm1 in proteasome localization required for KT homeostasis.

Plk1 bound to Bub1 contributes to spindle assembly checkpoint activity during mitosis

For faithful chromosome segregation, the formation of stable kinetochore–microtubule attachment and its monitoring by the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) are coordinately regulated by mechanisms that are currently ill-defined. Here, we show that polo-like kinase 1 (Plk1), which is instrumental in forming stable kinetochore–microtubule attachments, is also involved in the maintenance of SAC activity by binding to Bub1, but not by binding to CLASP2 or CLIP-170. The effect of Plk1 on the SAC was found to be mediated through phosphorylation of Mps1, an essential kinase for the SAC, as well as through phosphorylation of the MELT repeats in Knl1. Bub1 acts as a platform for assembling other SAC components on the phosphorylated MELT repeats. We propose that Bub1-bound Plk1 is important for the maintenance of SAC activity by supporting Bub1 localization to kinetochores in prometaphase, a time when the kinetochore Mps1 level is reduced, until the formation of stable kinetochore-microtubule attachment is completed. Our study reveals an intricate mechanism for coordinating the formation of stable kinetochore–microtubule attachment and SAC activity.