The coordinated electrical activity of ∼2 billion cardiac cells ensures stability of the heartbeat. Indeed, the remarkably low incidence (<1%) of ventricular arrhythmias in the healthy heart is only possible when the electrical event across this syncytium is closely controlled. In contrast, the diseased myocardium is associated with increased electrophysiological heterogeneity, unstable rhythm, and increased incidence of lethal arrhythmias. But what is the link between cellular and tissue level heterogeneity? Recent research has shown the existence of considerable cellular heterogeneity even in the healthy heart, suggesting that cell-to-cell variability in electrical (e.g. action potential duration) and mechanical performance (e.g. twitch amplitude) is a normal property. This observation has been previously unappreciated because the aggregated function in the form of QT-interval and cardiac output varies <1% on a beat-to-beat basis. This article describes the underlying cellular variability that is tolerated - and perhaps needed - by different regions of the heart for normal function and indicates why this variability is not apparent in function at the chamber and organ level. Thus, in contrast to the current dominant view, this article postulates that heterogeneity is normal and potentially endows various functional benefits. This new view of how the component parts of the heart come together to function also suggests novel mechanisms for cardiac pathologies, namely that dysfunction may emerge from changes in the extent and/or nature of heterogeneity. Once understood, restoring normal forms of heterogeneity could be a novel approach to treatment.