Bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)amide (Tf2N−) and triflate (TfO−) are commonly used anions of protic ionic liquids (PILs). They are the conjugate anions of strong acids, Tf2NH and TfOH, whose Brønsted acidities crucially influence the performance of the PILs. In this study, the Brønsted acidity of Tf2NH and TfOH was compared directly through potentiometric titrations carried out in the ionic liquids of ternary ammonium salts. As a result, Tf2NH exhibits stronger Brønsted acidity than TfOH by approximately 2 pH units. Furthermore, calorimetric titrations revealed that this difference originates from differences in their entropy states. This suggests that the solvation state, rather than the properties in their isolated state, has a more significant impact on the acidities of Tf2NH and TfOH. Besides, ionization thermodynamics turned out to be governed by both the constituent cations and anions of the PILs. Therefore, once the acid-base natures of the constituent ions are characterized, the overall acid-base behavior of the PIL may become predictable.