Sulfidation of nanoscale zerovalent iron (nZVI) can enhance particle performance. However, the underlying mechanisms of nZVI sulfidation are poorly known. We studied the effects of Fe2+ on 24-h dynamics of nZVI sulfidation by HS- using a dosed S to Fe molar ratio of 0.2. This shows that in the absence of Fe2+, HS- rapidly adsorbed onto nZVI particles and reacted with surface iron oxide to form mackinawite and greigite (<0.5 h). As nZVI corrosion progressed, amorphous FeSx in solution deposited on nZVI, forming S-nZVI (0.5-24 h). However, in the initial presence of Fe2+, the rapid reaction between HS- and Fe2+ produced amorphous FeSx, which deposited on the nZVI and corroded the surface iron oxide layer (<0.25 h). This was followed by redeposition of colloidal iron (hydr)oxide on the particle surface (0.25-8 h) and deposition of residual FeSx (8-24 h) on S-nZVI. S loading on S-nZVI was 1 order of magnitude higher when Fe2+ was present. Surface characterization of the sulfidated particles by TEM-SAED, XPS, and XAFS verified the solution dynamics and demonstrated that S2- and S22-/Sn2- were the principal reduced S species on S-nZVI. This study provides a methodology to tune sulfur loading and S speciation on S-nZVI to suit remediation needs.