An analysis is presented of reflection from a marine sediment consisting of a homogeneous mud layer overlying a sand-mud basement, the latter with an upward-refracting, inverse-square sound speed profile. Such layering is representative of the sediment at the New England Mud Patch (NEMP). By applying appropriate integral transforms and their inverses to the Helmholtz equations for the ocean and the two sediment layers, along with the boundary conditions, a Sommerfeld-Weyl type of wavenumber integral is obtained for the cylindrical-wave reflection coefficient of the sediment, R. A stationary phase evaluation of this integral yields a closed-form expression for the plane-wave reflection coefficient, R0. In the absence of attenuation, the plane-wave solution exhibits total reflection up to a critical grazing angle, ac, but when attenuation in the sediment is introduced, the region of total reflection in |R0| is replaced by a sequence of contiguous peaks. With realistic levels of sediment attenuation, the cylindrical-wave solution, |R|, exhibits a quasi-critical grazing angle, less than ac, which is strongly dependent on the source-plus-receiver height above the seabed, which is mildly dependent on the depth of the mud layer but is essentially independent of frequency. Such behavior is consistent with independent experimental observations at the NEMP.