THE PRESS RELEASE SEEMS SIMPLE enough: “The National Eye Institute of the National Institutes of Health will fund a new multicenter clinical trial to compare 2 drugs currently used to treat advanced agerelated macular degeneration (AMD).” But its ramifications are enormous. Thedrugsinquestionareranibizumab (Lucentis) and bevacizumab (Avastin), bothmanufacturedbyGenentechInc,of SouthSanFrancisco.Currently,only ranibizumab is approved by the US Food andDrugAdministration(FDA)fortreatingneovascularAMD.Anditworkswell, with more than 90% of patients reportingahalt invision lossandabout30%reporting improved sight. But a single dose of ranibizumab costs almost $2000 (or $48 000 for a typical 2-year course of monthly treatments). Although Medicare pays for ranibizumab, it covers only 80% of the cost, meaning that patients who do not have coinsurance pay $9600 out of pocket for a 2-year course. (Genentech does provide financial assistance and a free drug program for those who qualify who cannot pay for treatment.) As an alternative, a significant number of physicians are using bevacizumab off-label for AMD treatment. It costs about $40 a dose. Payers such as Medicare and patients who lack insurance or have copays will obviously experience huge cost savings if bevacizumab is found to be as effective as ranibizumab. Such a finding would also provide another treatment option for AMD in developing countries, where ranibizumab is generally not affordable. On the flip side, Genentech stands to lose billions of anticipated dollars if ranibizumab is abandoned for AMD treatment. ButbeyondGenentech,thebiotechand drug manufacturing industries are concernedabouttheprecedentcreatedbythis trial andcoulduse theirpolitical clout in an attempt to derail the study, said William Rich III, MD, medical director of healthpolicy for theAmericanAcademy of Ophthalmology in Washington, DC. “Obviously, biotech hates head-tohead trials based on efficacy and affecting payment,” Rich said. “I’m anticipating delays for this trial.” Indeed, while the $16.2 million trial was announced last year, and published reports had the study beginning in May or June, now researchers involved only say the trial will begin “sometime this summer.” Inexplainingwhy it isnotconducting orparticipating in this trial, aGenentech spokeswomansaidthecompanybelieves it has invented a highly successful treatment inranibizumab,anditwouldrather devoteitsresourcestoexplorewaysofexpanding the drug’s use for other eyerelatedissuessuchasdiabeticretinopathy. Age-relatedmaculardegenerationisthe leading cause of blindness in the developed world among people aged 50 years or older. In the United States, the prevalenceofpeoplewithvisuallossfromAMD is 1.2 million with about 200 000 new casesbeingreportedannually.About7.3 millionpeople in theUnitedStates areat risk of developing the condition. The neovascular form of AMD is characterized by abnormal growth of new blood vessels involving the macula. Scientists believe that vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)promotes thisneovascularization. Ranibizumab and bevacizumab are monoclonal antibodies that neutralize VEGF. Researchers originally considered using bevacizumab as a treatment for AMD, but it was thought that the molecule created was too big to penetrate the retina. Bevacizumab went on to become, in 2004, the first angiogenesis inhibitor approved by the FDA for treatment of colorectal cancer. In the meantime, researchers created ranibizumab by reengineering bevacizumab, resulting in a smaller molecule capable of passing through the retina. Butbefore ranibizumabreceivedFDA approval last year,physicians, facingpatientsdesperatetoavoidblindness,turned to bevacizumab, which they found improvedvisionwhilebeingwell tolerated. Soonpharmacistsweresubdividingquantities of bevacizumab intended for colorectalcancertreatmentintosmallerdoses forAMD.Today,anecdotalevidencesuggestsabouthalfofallpatientsbeingtreated for AMD receive bevacizumab. With so many patients receiving a drug off-label with anecdotally reported success, it is important to determine whether bevacizumab truly is safe and effective for AMD treatment, said Daniel Martin, MD, who will lead the National Eye Institute study.
Read full abstract