Introduction: Atypical atrial flutter (aAFL) has been described in the absence of prior atrial interventions, but prognosis for these patients after catheter ablation is poorly defined. This study was designed to define characteristics and ablation outcomes in patients with de novo aAFL. Methods: Patients with non-CTI flutter, without prior ablation or cardiac surgery, were identified from an institutional database. Clinical, mapping, ablation, and follow up data were compared to an equally sized group of randomly selected patients with typical flutter (tAFL). Results: The 35 patients with aAFL had 45 mapped non-CTI flutters. aAFL patients had similar age, gender, cardiovascular comorbidities, and LA size compared to tAFL, except aAFL patients had higher LVEF (54 ± 12 vs 46 ± 19%, p=0.04). Cycle length of aAFL was longer (268 [IQR 231, 310] vs 230 [220, 250] msec, p=0.0006). aAFL localized to the RA in 16, LA in 28, and biatrial in 1. Mechanisms were macroreentry in 23 (8 RA, 15 LA) and localized reentry in 22 (8 RA, 14 LA). Areas of scar predominated in the lateral/posterior RA (N=9), anterior LA (N=14), and posterior LA (N=6). Most common LA circuits were perimitral reentry (N=8) and roof dependent (N=8), including dual loop reentry. Localized reentry occurred most commonly in the anterior LA (N=7) or involved the pulmonary veins (N=4). Ablation was acutely successful for 41/45 aAFLs (91%) and for all tAFL. After median follow-up of 33 [6.6, 55] mo, atrial arrhythmias recurred in 23/34 aAFL patients (68%) and 24/35 tAFL patients (69%); those with aAFL had earlier recurrences (1.9 [0.43, 11] vs 19 [2.3, 36] mo, p=0.01). First recurrences after aAFL ablation were more likely to be AFL rather than AF (83% vs 17%) whereas tAFL patients were more likely to recur with AF (24% AFL vs 76% AF, p<0.0001). Conclusions: Patients with de novo aAFL tend to have spontaneous scar, commonly in the lateral/posterior RA and anterior LA, consistent with an atrial myopathy. Ablation can be accomplished with high acute success, but recurrent atrial arrhythmias are common, most re-presenting with atrial tachycardias. Future studies should clarify if a substrate-based approach or adjunctive antiarrhythmic drugs would result in better long term outcomes.
Read full abstract