The partial sterility of triploid (3n) oysters enables year-round harvest, improved meat quality, and superior growth compared to diploids. Two main techniques are used to produce shellfish triploids: 1) the ‘chemical induction’ method, where the release of polar body 2 in embryos is blocked via chemical treatment and 2) the ‘mated triploid’ method, widely used, where tetraploid (4n) males are crossed with diploid females to produce all triploid offspring. There have been growing concerns however that mated triploids may be more vulnerable to diseases or climate-driven stressors.In this research the long-term performance of selectively bred 3n oysters [Crassostrea (Magallana) gigas] obtained using different induction methods was evaluated both in the laboratory and in the field to identify any potential trade-offs from each method. Using genetically related parental stock, one diploid control (2n) and triploids derived from chemical induction (3nC) or mated triploids (3nM) were produced in the hatchery and multiple performance indicators - including growth, survival, reproductive effort, and tolerance to environmental stressors (OsHV-1 and acute heat stress) - were assessed at key life stages.Chemical induction yielded 96.3 % triploid D-larvae compared to 100 % for the mated triploids. Larval performances (e.g., survival) of 3nM and 2n were comparable, whereas 3nC had lower spat yield than 3nM. Triploid larvae grew faster than their related 2n, with no advantage amongst 3n groups. Lab-based OsHV-1 infection of spat showed no advantages from any groups with high survival across ploidy, while acute heat-stress challenges of adults showed that 3nM were more thermotolerant than 2n and 3nC.Remaining oysters were then deployed to multiple grow-out sites and their survival and growth assessed periodically. Field-survival after 20 months was high (>80 % for all groups) across all sites, with 3nM being on average 17 % larger than 3nC, and 40 % larger than their 2n counterparts. Combined number of eggs produced by 3nC and 3nM females was significantly lower than that of all 2n females (i.e., 5.5 % of 2n); however, reproductive potential amongst triploids was generally higher in 3nM than 3nC, particularly in oysters grown in warmer waters. Collectively, these findings inform stakeholders in assessing the feasibility of using tetraploids or direct chemical induction for 3n oyster spat production.
Read full abstract