The detection of a type 1 Brugada ECG is essential for diagnosis and risk stratification in Brugada syndrome. In this study, we evaluated the detection rate of a type 1 ECG on the multichannel Holter ECG, compared with the 12-lead ECGs recorded repeatedly. We enrolled consecutive 60 patients who had eventually exhibited a diagnostic type 1 ECG in the presence or absence of Na+ channel blockers at either standard or the third intercostal position. All patients underwent 12-lead ECGs recorded at both standard and the third intercostal position at least 5 times between 0 p.m and 2 p.m (4L-ECGs, 3L-ECGs, respectively). The 24-hour Holter ECG was performed in all patients, using a 12-lead Holter recording system. The precordial electrodes were attached at the standard position of V1, V2, V5, V6 and the third intercostal space of V1 and V2 (V1 IC3 , V2 IC3 , respectively). The leads V1 and V2, and V1 IC3 and V2 IC3 on the Holter ECG were expressed as 4L-Holter and 3L-Holter, respectively. The diagnostic type 1 ECG on the Holter ECG was defined as a presence of a coved-type ST-segment elevation >0.2mV over continuous 60 seconds at least one lead. We evaluated the detection rate of the type 1 ECG in 4L-ECGs, 3L-ECGs, 4L-Holter and 3L-Holter, and compared them among the 4 different recording methods. Among 60 patients, the patients showing the type 1 ECG on 4L-ECGs, 3L-ECGs, 4L-Holter and 3L-Holter were 15 (25%), 26 (43.3%), 23 (38.3%) and 33 patients (55%), respectively. The detection rate in 3L-ECGs and 3L-Holter was significantly larger than that in 4L-ECGs (p=0.03, p<0.001, respectively). Additionally, in 8 (23.5%) out of 34 patients with drug-induced type 1 ECG at standard and/or the third intercostal position, a spontaneous type 1 ECG was detected in 3L-Holter. Although the detection rate of a type 1 ECG in 3L-Holter was not significantly different with that in 3L-ECGs, the 3L-Holter was the most sensitive to detect a type 1 ECG among the 4 recording methods. In patients with Brugada type ECG, the Holter ECG recorded in the right precordial leads at the third intercostal space is more sensitive method to detect a diagnostic type 1 ECG than repeated 12-lead ECGs or the Holter ECG at standard position.
Read full abstract