Abstract The freshwater reservoir effect (FRE) was estimated for the northern part of West Siberia for the first time, based on securely dated samples from the late medieval town of Mangazeya existed mainly in AD 1601–1650. Twelve specimens of six species of freshwater fish were selected for 14C dating, and C and N stable isotopes analysis. The FRE varies from ca. 310 to ca. 1970 14C years, and there is no consistency in terms of relationship to feeding habits or trophic level of fish; the FRE fluctuations for Mangazeya, as well as for other regions in northern Eurasia, are noteworthy. This information should be taken into account when 14C dating of bones of humans and domestic animals, who consume significant amount of freshwater fish, is conducted. This also applies to 14C dating of food crusts on the surface of pottery.