Variability of NmF2 during solar minima at the Equatorial Ionization Anomaly crest region

Abstract

The variability of NmF2 during solar minima of solar cycle 21–22, 22–23 and 23–24 has been studied for two low latitude stations, Karachi (Pakistan) and Okinawa (Japan), as both stations are situated at the Equatorial Ionization Anomaly (EIA) crest region. Diurnal, seasonal and annual behaviour of variability has been investigated using relative standard deviation approach. At both the stations, a direct relation of variability (CV) with Smoothed Sunspot Numbers (SSN) is noted which is opposite to the results found by many authors who have worked on different solar activity periods. It is suggested that the E-layer is responsible for this direct relation as an increase in the E-layer ionization with decrease in SSN for solar minimum has also been noted for Karachi in our previous work (Talha et al., 2019). The interaction of tides and waves with the E-layer might be responsible for the increase in ionization of the E-layer and the decrease in variability in the F-layer. Also, the night-time variability is observed to be higher than the daytime variability during minima as expected due to the low mean NmF2 or large deviation during night-time. Very prominent post-midnight peaks and not very well shaped post-sunset peaks are also noticed at both stations. Besides the mentioned peaks, a small increase in variability during mid-day is noticed which might be due to the flow of fountain plasma from the equator to the EIA crest region. Seasonal comparison of variability showed high variability during daytime in winter and during night-time in equinox while lowest variability is noted in summer. Lowest variability at post-midnight is noted in winter instead of summer which might be due to the complex interaction of waves and tides with the lower ionosphere. Small difference in variability between both stations is also noticed due to difference in their longitude. Geomagnetic field configuration at both stations is different which in turn causes change in the electron density and also difference in variability at both stations.