Validation of Models for Net Deployment and Capture Simulation with Experimental Data

Abstract

This work validates lumped-parameter models and cable-based models for nets against data from a parabolic flight experiment. The capabilities of a simulator based in Vortex Studio, a multibody dynamics simulation framework, are expanded by introducing i) a lumped-parameter model of the net with lumped masses placed along the threads and ii) a flexible-cable-based model, both of which enable collision detection with thin bodies. An experimental scenario is recreated in simulation, and the deployment and capture phases are analyzed. Good agreement with experiments is observed in both phases, although with differences primarily due to imperfect knowledge of experimental initial conditions. It is demonstrated that both a lumped-parameter model with inner nodes and a cable-based model can enable the detection of collisions between the net and thin geometries of the target. While both models improve notably capture realism compared to a lumped parameter model with no inner nodes, the cable-based model is found to be most computationally efficient. The effect of modeling thread-to-thread collisions (i.e., collisions among parts of the net) is analyzed and determined to be negligible during deployment and initial target wrapping. The results of this work validate the models and increase the confidence in the practicality of this simulator as a tool for research on net-based capture of debris. A cable-based model is validated for the first time in the literature.