Vaguening Revenge: Beckett, Marston, and All That Fall

Abstract

At the beginning of Samuel Beckett’s radio play, All That Fall, Mrs Rooney famously forgets her lines: she cannot quite remember the precise phrase that she strains to recall from John Ford’s The Lover’s Melancholy. However, what has been overlooked is Beckett’s own forgetfulness as to the origins of this intertextual reference. Repeatedly, he attributes this line (and others from his wider stock of notes) to one of Ford’s close contemporaries: John Marston. This article recovers Beckett’s many mistaken allusions to Marston, and begins to think through the ways in which his curious recurrence in Beckett’s thinking at the time of All That Fall’s composition might betray a particular interest in the revenge genre (in which Marston is so influential). It posits that, in writing All That Fall, Beckett works to ‘vaguen’ many of the formal tropes that recur over the course of revenge drama’s long literary history. It then goes on to explore the possibility that this play for voices might engage specifically with this generic tradition in order to stage a critique of religion.