Utilizing fMRI to Guide TMS Targets: the Reliability and Sensitivity of fMRI Metrics at 3T and 1.5T.

Abstract

US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) cleared a Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) system with functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging-guided (fMRI) individualized treatment protocol for major depressive disorder, which employs resting state-fMRI (RS-fMRI) functional connectivity (FC) to pinpoint the target individually to increase the accuracy and effeteness of the stimulation. Furthermore, task activation-guided TMS, as well as the use of RS-fMRI local metrics for targeted the specific abnormal brain regions, are considered a precise scheme for TMS targeting. Since 1.5T MRI is more available in hospitals, systematic evaluation of the test-retest reliability and sensitivity of fMRI metrics on 1.5T and 3T MRI may provide reference for the application of fMRI-guided individualized-precise TMS stimulation. Twenty participants underwent three RS-fMRI scans and one scan of finger-tapping task fMRI with self-initiated (SI) and visual-guided (VG) conditions at both 3T and 1.5T. Then the location reliability derived by FC (with three seed regions) and peak activation were assessed by intra-individual distance. The test-retest reliability and sensitivity of five RS-fMRI local metrics were evaluated using intra-class correlation and effect size, separately. The intra-individual distance of peak activation location between 1.5T and 3T was 15.8mm and 19mm for two conditions, respectively. The intra-individual distance for the FC derived targets at 1.5T was 9.6-31.2mm, compared to that of 3T (7.6-31.1mm). The test-retest reliability and sensitivity of RS-fMRI local metrics showed similar trends on 1.5T and 3T. These findings hasten the application of fMRI-guided individualized TMS treatment in clinical practice.