Utility of the metatarsal diaphyseal nutrient foramen in estimating sex in the South African Africans population

Abstract

IntroductionSex estimation is challenging in cases where dismembered or non-intact skeletal remains are recovered. Therefore, the development of sex estimation standards using various bones that present with high recovery rates during forensic investigations, like the metatarsal bones, is needed. The usefulness of the dimensions around the metatarsal diaphyseal nutrient foramen in sex estimation has not been assessed in South African Africans (SAA), constituting the majority of the country's population. Materials and methodsFive measurements around the nutrient foramen were taken from 995 metatarsal bones (first to fifth) from 200 individual skeletons (100 males, 100 females). Measurements subjected to direct and stepwise discriminant function (DFA) and logistic regression (LRA) analyses included the total length, distance from proximal end to nutrient foramen, circumference, and mediolateral and dorsoplantar diameters at the level of the nutrient foramen. ResultsThe original classification accuracies for multivariable functions of the stepwise and direct DFA ranged from 75.1 to 80 % and 76–79.5 % respectively. The original classification accuracies for multivariable functions of the stepwise and direct LRA ranged from 76.3% to 79.5 % and 75%–80.5 % respectively. The cross-validation classifications showed a drop of 0–2% for DFA and 0.2–1.9 % for LRA. Overall breadth measurements showed better classification accuracies than length measurements and females were classified with higher accuracy rates than males. ConclusionThe dimensions around the nutrient foramen of the metatarsal bones show sexual dimorphism in the SAA. The generated DFA and LRA functions produced high average classification accuracies which can be appropriate for use in sex estimation in forensic settings, especially when an isolated foot is recovered.