Use of reconstituted kefir consortia to determine the impact of microbial composition on kefir metabolite profiles

Abstract

Kefir is fermented traditionally with kefir grains, but commercial kefir production often relies on fermentation with planktonic cultures. Kefir has been associated with many health benefits, however, the utilization of kefir grains to facilitate large industrial production of kefir is challenging and makes to difficult to ensure consistent product quality and consistency. Notably, the microbial composition of kefir fermentations has been shown to impact kefir associated health benefits. This study aimed to compare volatile compounds, organic acids, and sugar composition of kefir produced through a traditional grain fermentation and through a reconstituted kefir consortium fermentation. Additionally, the impact of two key microbial communities on metabolite production in kefir was assessed using two modified versions of the consortium, with either yeasts or lactobacilli removed. We hypothesized that the complete kefir consortium would closely resemble traditional kefir, while the consortia without yeasts or lactobacilli would differ significantly from both traditional kefir and the complete consortium fermentation. Kefir fermentations were examined after 12 and 18 h using two-dimensional gas chromatography-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (GC × GC-TOFMS) to identify volatile compounds and high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to identify organic acid and sugar composition. The traditional kefir differed significantly from the kefir consortium fermentation with the traditional kefir having 15–20 log2(fold change) higher levels of esters and the consortium fermented kefir having between 1 and 3 log2(fold change) higher organic acids including lactate and acetate. The use of a version of kefir consortium that lacked lactobacilli resulted in between 2 and 20 log2(fold change) lower levels of organic acids, ethanol, and butanoic acid ethyl ester, while the absence of yeast from the consortium resulted in minimal change. In summary, the kefir consortium fermentation is significantly different from traditional grain fermented kefir with respect to the profile of metabolites present, and seems to be driven by lactobacilli, as evidenced by the significant decrease in multiple metabolites when the lactobacilli were removed from the fermentation and minimal differences observed upon the removal of yeast.