Abstract
Radiocarbon date frequency distributions and archaeological site counts are two popular proxies used to investigate prehistoric demography, following the assumption that variations in these data reflect fluctuations in the relative size and distribution of past populations. However, the two approaches are rarely applied to the same data-set and their applicability is heavily conditioned by the archaeological record in question, particularly research histories, agendas, and funding availability. In this paper we use both types of data to examine the population history of the Upper Palaeolithic hunter–gatherers (∼40 000–12 000 cal BP) of Southwestern France, comparing the demographic signatures generated.Both proxies produce similar signatures across the Upper Palaeolithic sequence of the region, strengthening the interpretation of relative demographic changes as the cause of the pattern. In particular, a marked population decline is seen in both datasets during the Late Gravettian (∼28 000 cal BP), as well as a population increase in the Late Solutrean (∼25 000 cal BP) supporting the notion that the region acted as a population refugium during the Last Glacial Maximum. Where the two proxies diverge in the demographic signatures they produce, the radiocarbon date distribution shows peaks compared to troughs in site counts; the opposite pattern expected given taphonomic issues surrounding cultural carbon. Despite differences in chronological resolution and sampling bias, our data suggest that the two proxies can be considered broadly equivalent; a finding which warrants the investigation of prehistoric demography in regions where either extensive survey data or radiometric dating programmes are unavailable. While some preliminary observations are made, the impact of changing mobility on diachronic patterns seen in both proxies remains, however, difficult to assess.
Highlights
Two popular archaeological approaches to investigating past population histories are examining temporal frequency distributions of the number of archaeological sites and radiocarbon (14C) dates
The two distributions are clearly very different, which we interpret as indicating that population density fluctuated throughout the Upper Palaeolithic in Southwestern France
While increased mobility cannot be discounted as a possible explanation, given the role of the study region as a refugium during this cold phase, we suggest that the overall trend of a negative correlation between temperature and population seen in the 14C probability distribution indicates that Southwestern France may have acted as a refugium for hunteregatherer populations during other cold stages of the Upper Palaeolithic (Bertran et al, 2013: 2274)
Summary
Two popular archaeological approaches to investigating past population histories are examining temporal frequency distributions of the number of archaeological sites and radiocarbon (14C) dates. Collins / Journal of Archaeological Science 55 (2015) 122e134 remains largely untested Following both previous studies which compare the two methods (Tallavaara et al, 2010), and calls for a multi-proxy approach to aid the verification and interpretation of palaeodemographic trends (Crombe and Robinson, in press; French, in press; Williams, 2012), we present here a comparison of the demographic signatures of 14C date distributions and archaeological site counts using the case study of the hunteregatherer populations of the Upper Palaeolithic (~40 000e12 000 cal BP) of Southwestern France
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
