Uncertainty in the embodied energy assessment of buildings: a case of EWS type low-cost house in India

Abstract

Studies on embodied energy of buildings often present results as a single-point estimate without considering the variability in input parameters and the uncertainty it poses on results. Uncertainty analysis is useful to improve the reliability of results. This study examines uncertainty in the embodied energy of a single-storey EWS type residential building due to variability in the embodied energy intensity of materials and material wastage factors. Data quality indicator (DQI) based semi-qualitative method is used for modelling the variability in input parameters. Monte Carlo Simulation is used for uncertainty propagation. The building embodied energy is found to vary from 4 to 9 GJ/m2 based on variation in input data. The mean building embodied energy is found to be 6.3 GJ/m2. The embodied energy intensity of materials is found to cause more variation in building embodied energy in comparison with mass of materials. 'Brick’ is identified as the significant key parameter based on the relative contribution to uncertainty and embodied energy at the building level. Cement and rebar are identified as key parameters. The DQI based methodology presented in this study is useful for Life Cycle Assessment practitioners to evaluate uncertainty in the embodied energy assessment of residential buildings.