Tracing tungsten-tin mineralization processes with tourmaline geochemistry in the Wangxianling-Hehuaping district, Nanling Range (South China)

Abstract

The mechanisms controlling the enrichment and separate precipitation of tungsten and tin ores are obscure. To unravel the physicochemical changes in the mineralization system during the magmatic-hydrothermal transition, we investigate the petrography, geochemistry, and boron isotopes of tourmaline in the Wangxianling-Hehuaping district (Nanling Range, South China). Four types of tourmalines were identified: Magmatic (Tur-WG) and hydrothermal (Tur-WV) tourmaline in the Triassic W-mineralized tourmaline-two-mica granite (ca. 220 Ma); Magmatic (Tur-SnG) and hydrothermal (Tur-SnV) tourmaline in the Jurassic Sn-mineralized biotite granite (ca. 155 Ma). Tur-WV and Tur-SnV have lower Fe3+/(Fe2+ + Fe3+) ratios than those of Tur-WG and Tur-SnG, suggesting that W-Sn mineralization occurred in a relatively reducing environment. In addition, the δ11B values of all four types of tourmalines are similar, suggesting that the ore-forming fluids were primarily exsolved from the granitic magma. Significant chemical variations (e.g., Mg, Fe, Sc, V, Ni, and REEs) between Tur-SnG and Tur-SnV may have been resulted from fractionation and intense ore fluid-wall rock reactions. In contrast, Tur-WG has similar chemical compositions to Tur-WV, suggesting that the Triassic W mineralization may have undergone a magmatic-hydrothermal process with little ore fluid-wall reaction. Tur-SnV has exceptionally high F content, which could enhance the Sn solubility and enrichment. This explains the low Sn content of granitic magmas with large-scale Jurassic tin mineralization. Considering that W has a large melt-fluid partition coefficient, we conclude that in the Triassic, W is enriched in the exsolved fluid from the granitic magma and precipitated with temperature drop. This may have caused the decrease in W content in the protolith and limited the Jurassic W mineralization. Subsequently, the mantle-derived F addition along the Chenzhou-Linwu fault in the Jurassic had led to Sn enrichment in the fluids, and mineralization is triggered by temperature drop and fluid-rock reactions. Eventually, the extensive Triassic W mineralization and Jurassic Sn mineralization exhibit the separation of tungsten-tin mineralization. The separated tungsten-tin mineralization model based on different volatile components could also be applicable to other tungsten-tin metallogenic belts.