Total cystectomy after intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin (Tokyo strain) therapy for superficial bladder cancer: Experience in Japan

Abstract

To clarify which patients might most require total cystectomy after intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) therapy, we reviewed data for 111 individuals with superficial bladder cancer. Of the 111 patients, 73 received the BCG treatment for prophylaxis of intravesical recurrence after transurethral resection (group 1), 24 therapeutically for Ta or T1 tumours (group 2), and 14 for eradicating carcinomas in situ (CIS, group 3). Although the BCG therapy significantly reduced frequencies of recurrence in group 1, 27 patients (37%) did develop tumours again. Tumours disappeared in 18 of 24 patients (75%) in group 2, and in 11 of 14 (79%) in group 3. The rate of disease progression was 6% for all 111 patients: 3% (2/73) for group 1, 17% (4/24) for group 2, and 7% (1/14) for group 3. A total of 16 of the 111 patients (14%) underwent total cystectomy, the respective figures being 7% in group 1, 29% in group 2, and 29% in group 3. Indications for total cystectomy were progression in 7, recurrent multiple tumours in 5, persistent CIS in 2, a contracted bladder in 1, and occurrence of bilateral renal pelvic cancer in 1. Thus, 4 of 6 patients (67%) who had tumours unresponsive to BCG therapy in group 2 demonstrated progression and necessitated total cystectomy. Because tumours persisting after BCG therapy are frequently of the muscle-invasive type, such cases should be regarded as candidates for immediate total cystectomy.