Three lines of evidence in a sediment toxicity evaluation for hexachlorobutadiene

Abstract

Three approaches were used in a site-specific sediment toxicity evaluation for hexachlorobutadiene (HCBD), a chemical not previously tested for toxicity in sediment. The results of a sediment dilution study, spiked sediment toxicity tests, and a probabilistic model based on equilibrium partitioning theory were used to estimate ecological effects thresholds for HCBD in sediments of a Gulf Coast estuary. Twenty-nine sediment samples, including 11 undiluted samples and six dilution series, were tested for toxicity under estuarine conditions (10%0 salinity) using Hyalella azteca and Leptocheirus plumulosus. Site sediment was used as diluent, and all samples were assayed for a range of organic and inorganic chemicals. A logistic relationship was observed between HCBD concentrations and organism response, and nonlinear regression explained approximately 90% of the observed variation in amphipod survival as a function of HCBD. Spiked sediment toxicity test results generally agreed with the results of the dilution study, demonstrating the causality of the observed concentration–response relationship. Effects thresholds were estimated as HCBD concentrations corresponding to 80% amphipod survival. The most conservative effects thresholds from the spiked sediment and dilution studies were 0.63 mg/kg normalized to 1% total organic carbon (mg/kg1%OC) for H. azteca and 1.4 mg/kg1%OC for L. plumulosus. Aquatic LC50s for 10 species and a measured acute–chronic ratio from the published literature were used to predict a distribution of sediment effects thresholds for HCBD, with 10th and 90th percentile values of 2.6 and 45 mg/kg1%OC, respectively. The predicted and observed sediment effects thresholds thus agreed relatively well, although the H. azteca and L. plumulosus test results from this study seem to be somewhat more conservative than the majority of published aquatic toxicity test results.