Therapeutic Indices of Topical Antiseptics in Wound Care: A Systematic Review.

Abstract

Chronic wounds place a heavy burden on healthcare systems and markedly reduce the ability of patients to engage in activities of daily living. One major factor contributing to impaired wound healing is bacterial bioburden. With the rise in antibiotic resistance and the slowdown in antibiotic development pipelines, alternative antimicrobial strategies are important. The objective of this systematic review is to determine the topical antiseptic therapeutic index values for bacterial species commonly isolated from chronic wounds. The therapeutic index is a ratio of the lowest concentration that causes mammalian cell cytotoxicity over the minimum bactericidal concentration. Higher values indicate greater safety and potential clinical benefit. A systematic literature search was performed in Medline and Embase, resulting in the inclusion of 37 articles that reported on the minimum bactericidal concentration in bacterial species commonly isolated from chronic wounds and their cytotoxicity concentrations in mammalian cells. The therapeutic indices for the topical antiseptics included in this study were generally low, with most ranging between 0.5-3.0. The highest therapeutic index values for Escherichia coli (5.49), Staphylococcus aureus (6.31) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (8.81) were achieved by hypochlorous acid, whereas the highest therapeutic index values for methicillin resistant S aureus (12.1) was achieved by polyhexamethylenebiguanide. Antibiotic stewardship principles may need to be applied to topical antiseptics due to some isolated evidence of topical antiseptic resistance and cross-resistance to antibiotics. The choice of antiseptic should not be made solely based on therapeutic index values, but individualized to the patient, with consideration for the wound healing condition that may include covert infection.