Theory of epigenetic switching due to stochastic histone mark loss during DNA replication

Epigenetic regulation of cellular identity and function is at least partly achieved through changes in covalent modifications on DNA and histones. Much progress has been made in recent years to understand how these covalent modifications affect cell identity and function. Despite the advances, whether and how epigenetic factors contribute to memory formation is still poorly understood. In this review, we discuss recent progress in elucidating epigenetic mechanisms of learning and memory, primarily at the DNA level, and look ahead to discuss their potential implications in reward memory and development of drug addiction.

In order for the genome to be faithfully maintained, chromosomal DNA must be precisely replicated and segregated in each cell cycle. Over the last decade an enormous amount has been learned about how this is achieved. Much of the progress has come from genetic analysis in yeast. However, biochemical analysis of cell cycle events using extracts prepared from eggs of the South African clawed toad Xenopus laevis has also played an important role. Although there are differences in the detailed regulation of the yeast and frog cell cycles, the basic cell cycle machinery appears to have been conserved throughout evolution. The results obtained in these model organisms, therefore, seem likely to be generally applicable to the cell cycles of all eukaryotes. ### Xenopus eggs and egg extracts The fertilized Xenopus egg undergoes 12 synchronous rounds of cell division in ∼8 h. These cell divisions take place in the absence of growth, subdividing the large (∼1 mm diameter) single‐celled egg into ∼4000 smaller cells. Transcription does not occur during these early embryonic divisions, although translation of pre‐existing maternal mRNA continues. Most of the proteins required for cell cycle progression are pre‐formed in the egg, and the continuing translation of a single protein (cyclin B) can support passage through the whole cell cycle (Murray and Kirschner, 1989). The stockpile of cell cycle proteins present in the Xenopus egg became exploitable by biochemical means following the development of cell‐free extracts that support all the nuclear events of the early embryonic cell division cycle (Lohka and Masui, 1983). Gentle lysis associated with minimal dilution of the cytoplasm yields a ‘low speed supernatant’ that maintains all the cell cycle activities present in the intact egg. These ‘low speed supernatants’ support precise rounds of DNA replication on exogenously added DNA templates, and like the intact egg, only re‐replicate DNA after passage through …

The geminin protein is a critical regulator of DNA replication. It functions to control replication fidelity by blocking the assembly of prereplication complexes in the S and G(2) phases of the cell cycle. Geminin protein levels, which are low in G(0)/G(1) and increase at the G(1)/S transition, are controlled through coordinate transcriptional and proteolytic regulation. Here we show that geminin is regulated transcriptionally by the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (RB)/E2F pathway. Initially, we observed that the activation of RB led to the repression of geminin transcription. Conversely, Rb-null mouse embryonic fibroblasts have enhanced the expression of geminin relative to wild type mouse embryonic fibroblasts. Similarly, an acute loss of Rb in mouse adult fibroblasts deregulated geminin RNA and protein levels. To delineate the responsible regulatory motifs, luciferase reporter constructs containing fragments of the geminin promoter were generated. An analysis of the critical regulatory cis-acting elements in the geminin promoter indicated that intragenic E2F sites down-stream of the first exon were responsible for RB-mediated repression of geminin. The direct analysis of the endogenous geminin promoter revealed that these intragenic E2F sites are occupied by E2F proteins, and the mutation of these sites eliminates responsiveness to RB. Together, these data link the expression of geminin to the RB/E2F pathway and represent the first promoter analysis of this important regulator of DNA replication.

Dynamic Spatial Regulation in the Bacterial Cell

Epigenetic modifications, including DNA methylation, stably alter gene expression without modifying genomic sequences. Recent evidence suggests that epigenetic regulation coupled with a long-term 'memory' effect plays a major role within bacterial persistence formation. Today, emerging high-resolution, single-molecule sequencing technologies allow an increased focus on DNA modifications as regulatory epigenetic marks, which presents a unique opportunity to identify possible epigenetic drivers of bacterial persistence.

Mammalian cyclin D-Cdk4 complexes have been characterized as growth factor-responsive cell cycle regulators. Their levels rise upon growth factor stimulation, and they can phosphorylate and thus neutralize Retinoblastoma (Rb) family proteins to promote an E2F-dependent transcriptional program and S-phase entry. Here we characterize the in vivo function of Drosophila Cyclin D (CycD). We find that Drosophila CycD-Cdk4 does not act as a direct G(1)/S-phase regulator, but instead promotes cellular growth (accumulation of mass). The cellular response to CycD-Cdk4-driven growth varied according to cell type. In undifferentiated proliferating wing imaginal cells, CycD-Cdk4 caused accelerated cell division (hyperplasia) without affecting cell cycle phasing or cell size. In endoreplicating salivary gland cells, CycD-Cdk4 caused excessive DNA replication and cell enlargement (hypertrophy). In differentiating eyes, CycD-Cdk4 caused cell enlargement (hypertrophy) in post-mitotic cells. Interaction tests with a Drosophila Rb homolog, RBF, indicate that CycD-Cdk4 can counteract the cell cycle suppressive effects of RBF, but that its growth promoting activity is mediated at least in part via other targets.

In the mouse zygote, Stella/PGC7 protects 5-methylcytosine (5mC) of the maternal genome from Tet3-mediated oxidation to 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC). Although ablation of Stella causes early embryonic lethality, the underlying molecular mechanisms remain unknown. In this study, we report impaired DNA replication and abnormal chromosome segregation (ACS) of maternal chromosomes in Stella-null embryos. In addition, phosphorylation of H2AX (γH2AX), which has been reported to inhibit DNA replication, accumulates in the maternal chromatin of Stella-null zygotes in a Tet3-dependent manner. Cell culture assays verified that ectopic appearance of 5hmC induces abnormal accumulation of γH2AX and subsequent growth retardation. Thus, Stella protects maternal chromosomes from aberrant epigenetic modifications to ensure early embryogenesis.

The budding yeast Cdc6 protein (Cdc6p) is essential for formation of pre-replicative complexes (pre-RCs) at origins of DNA replication. Regulation of pre-RC assembly plays a key role in making initiation of DNA synthesis dependent upon passage through mitosis and in limiting DNA replication to once per cell cycle. Cdc6p is normally only present at high levels during the G1 phase of the cell cycle. This is partly because the CDC6 gene is only transcribed during G1. In this article we show that rapid degradation of Cdc6p also contributes to this periodicity. Cdc6p degradation rates are regulated during the cell cycle, reaching a peak during late G1/early S phase. Removal of a 47-amino-acid domain near the N-terminus of Cdc6p prevents degradation of Cdc6p. Likewise, mutations in the Cdc4/34/53 pathway involved in ubiquitin-mediated degradation block proteolysis and genetic evidence is presented indicating that the N-terminus of Cdc6p interacts with the Cdc4/34/53 pathway, probably through Cdc4p. A stable Cdc6p mutant which is no longer degraded by the Cdc4/34/53 pathway is, none the less, fully functional. Constitutive overexpression of either wild-type or stable Cdc6p does not induce re-replication and does not induce assembly of pre-replicative complexes after DNA replication is complete.

Chk1 is a conserved kinase that imposes cell cycle delays in response to impediments to DNA replication. Recent experiments have further defined effects of Chk1 on the activity of mammalian origins of DNA replication and progression of replication forks. Moreover, Chk1 now appears to help defend genomic integrity through effects on several other pathways, including Fanconi anemia proteins, the mitotic spindle, and transcription of cell cycle-related genes. These findings can account for the requirement for Chk1 in normal proliferating cells of the early embryo and suggest the potential for diverse effects of Chk1 inhibition in cancer therapy.

Cell Size Control in Bacteria

Cdc7 is a serine/threonine kinase that plays essential roles in the initiation of eukaryotic DNA replication and checkpoint response. In previous studies, depletion of Cdc7 by small interfering RNA was shown to induce an abortive S phase that led to the cell cycle arrest in normal human fibroblasts and apoptotic cell death in various cancer cells. Here we report that stress-activated p38 MAP kinase was activated and responsible for apoptotic cell death in Cdc7-depleted HeLa cells. The activation of p38 MAP kinase in the Cdc7-depleted cells was shown to depend on ATR, a major sensor kinase for checkpoint or DNA damage responses. Only the p38 MAP kinase, and not the other stress-activated kinases such as JNK or ERK, was activated, and both caspase 8 and caspase 9 were activated for the induction of apoptosis. Activation of apoptosis in Cdc7-depleted cells was completely abolished in cells treated with small interfering RNA or an inhibitor of the p38 MAP kinase, suggesting that p38 MAP kinase activation was responsible for apoptotic cell death. Taken together, we suggest that the ATR-dependent activation of the p38 MAP kinase is a major signaling pathway that induces apoptotic cell death after depletion of Cdc7 in cancer cells.

We identified YDR499W as a Saccharomyces cerevisiae open reading frame with homology to several checkpoint proteins, including S. cerevisiae Rfc5p and Schizosaccharomyces pombe Rad26. Disruption of YDR499W (termed LCD1) results in lethality that is rescued by increasing cellular deoxyribonucleotide levels. Cells lacking LCD1 are very sensitive to a range of DNA-damaging agents, including UV irradiation, and to the inhibition of DNA replication. LCD1 is necessary for the phosphorylation and activation of Rad53p in response to DNA damage or DNA replication blocks, and for Chk1p activation in response to DNA damage. LCD1 is also required for efficient DNA damage-induced phosphorylation of Rad9p and for the association of Rad9p with the FHA2 domain of Rad53p after DNA damage. In addition, cells lacking LCD1 are completely defective in the G(1)/S and G(2)/M DNA damage checkpoints. Finally, we reveal that endogenous Mec1p co-immunoprecipitates with Lcd1p both before and after treatment with DNA-damaging agents. These results indicate that Lcd1p is a pivotal checkpoint regulator, involved in both the essential and checkpoint functions of the Mec1p pathway.

The retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (RB) is functionally inactivated in many human cancers. Classically, RB functions to repress E2F-mediated transcription and inhibit cell cycle progression. Consequently, RB ablation leads to loss of cell cycle control and aberrant expression of E2F target genes. Emerging evidence indicates a role for RB in maintenance of genomic stability. Here, mouse adult fibroblasts were utilized to demonstrate that aberrant DNA content in RB-deficient cells occurs concomitantly with an increase in levels and chromatin association of DNA replication factors. Furthermore, following exposure to nocodazole, RB-proficient cells arrest with 4 n DNA content, whereas RB-deficient cells bypass the mitotic block, continue DNA synthesis, and accumulate cells with higher ploidy and micronuclei. Under this condition, RB-deficient cells also retain high levels of tethered replication factors, MCM7 and PCNA, indicating that DNA replication occurs in these cells under nonpermissive conditions. Exogenous expression of replication factors Cdc6 or Cdt1 in RB-proficient cells does not recapitulate the RB-deficient cell phenotype. However, ectopic E2F expression in RB-proficient cells elevated ploidy and bypassed the response to nocodazole-induced cessation of DNA replication in a manner analogous to RB loss. Collectively, these results demonstrate that deregulated S phase control is a key mechanism by which RB-deficient cells acquire elevated ploidy.

One of the most critically important processes in any living organism, essential for development and reproduction, is that of the accurate replication of its genome before each cell division. The process of DNA replication can take place millions of times in a single organism and any mistake, if left unrepaired, is potentially transmitted into the next generation. Errors during replication can result in genetic mutations or karyotype aberrations, both of which can lead to disease or death. The duplication of the genome happens in a well-conserved spatio-temporal manner, a phenomenon implicated in development and disease. This fact indicates that DNA replication needs to be tightly regulated. Further, its precise coordination suggests that distinct genomic regions undergo replication at specific times during S-phase. On the other hand, the regulation of replication is a flexible process throughout development and is, therefore, proposed to be controlled epigenetically. However, the complexity of the mammalian nucleus has hampered the elucidation of how chromatin structure can regulate replication timing. In fact, our understanding of the regulation of replication timing in mammals is restricted to only a few studies with, in part, seemingly contradicting results. In the context of the present thesis, I set out to study the epigenetic mechanisms that control DNA replication dynamics in mammalian cells. To this end, I took advantage of the most prominent example of facultative heterochromatin, the epigenetically silenced X chromosome (Xi) of female mammalian cells, as well as of the mouse chromocenters, formed by clusters of constitutive heterochromatin. To study their particular replication dynamics and the epigenetic mechanisms controlling them, I used a set of genetic (conditional) knockouts, chemical inhibitory treatments and differentiation assays. The latter allowed me to control whole-chromosome inactivation and the subsequent establishment of the corresponding replication pattern, as well as to distinguish the contribution of different epigenetic markers in this process. I visualized the epigenetic changes and their effects on the replication program in situ by immunostainings, also in combination with fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), confocal and super resolution light microscopy, as well as in vivo by time-lapse microscopy over peri-ods of up to two days. This approach prompted the development of several tools for live-cell analysis. Using established and new tools, I comprehensively assessed the Xi replication dynamics and the effects of modulating different epigenetic modifications of heterochromatin, their cros-stalk and the subsequent effects on DNA replication timing and was able to show that histone hypoacetylation, a common mark of the Xi and chromocenters, is responsible for the delayed initiation in replication of both heterochromatic regions. Consequently, I propose that histone hyperacetylation, probably due to its opening effect on chromatin structure, renders some genomic regions prone to be bound by initiation factors earlier and / or more abundantly. This preferential binding, e.g. by replication initiation factors, would thus lead to earlier and concomitantly more efficient replication origin firing. Moreover, I discuss the causal relation between transcriptional inactivity and synchronous replication dynamics, a common feature of developmentally opposite systems, such as the mammalian Xi and the embryos of flies and frogs.

SummaryThe AAA+ ATPase VCP regulates the extraction of SUMO and ubiquitin-modified DNA replication factors from chromatin. We have previously described that active DNA synthesis is associated with a SUMO-high/ubiquitin-low environment governed by the deubiquitylase USP7. Here, we unveil a functional cooperation between USP7 and VCP in DNA replication, which is conserved from Caenorhabditis elegans to mammals. The role of VCP in chromatin is defined by its cofactor FAF1, which facilitates the extraction of SUMOylated and ubiquitylated proteins that accumulate after the block of DNA replication in the absence of USP7. The inactivation of USP7 and FAF1 is synthetically lethal both in C. elegans and mammalian cells. In addition, USP7 and VCP inhibitors display synergistic toxicity supporting a functional link between deubiquitylation and extraction of chromatin-bound proteins. Our results suggest that USP7 and VCPFAF1 facilitate DNA replication by controlling the balance of SUMO/Ubiquitin-modified DNA replication factors on chromatin.