The Strength of the Sense of Shame of the Aged in Care Scenes: Comparison Between Whether or not There is Anyone Else Around Them

Abstract

Medical staff in a hospital or nursing facility should take care of aged individuals with dignity and respect. We conducted a survey on aged individuals to derive under what care circumstances they had a sense of shame, using 12 illustrations, drawn by ourselves, which were common daily care scenes where nurses and patients meet. This survey was conducted at 4 care facilities in A prefecture, Japan. The number of surveyed persons was 43, with the following exclusion criteria: over 60 years old, more than third level of care needed, and non suspected of having dementia. We got the following results from the answers of 41 persons: 1. When elder persons are surrounded by people other than the care staff, they feel more of a sense of shame than when alone; 2. They feel more sense of shame when they use a wheelchair than when they use crutches; 3. They do not feel much shame when they get a bed-bath, even if other persons are there; and 4. Male patients feel more shame than females when they meet their family. These results suggest that elderly patients feel a stronger sense of shame when they are seen by others than when they are seen by care staff. The result 2 suggests that the use of a wheelchair exposes their physical weakness to others. Males feel a stronger sense of shame when they show a weakness in their gender role. We conclude that the sense of shame of aged individuals in daily life scenes in a care facility depends on their gender and whether or not they are surrounded by other persons.