The Role of an Avian Nectar Robber and of Hummingbird Pollinators in the Reproduction of Two Plant Species

Abstract

1. Flower nectar robbers which extract flower rewards to pollinators but do not pollinate, may reduce the fitness of the plant. In this study we combined field observations and experimental manipulations to assess the role of a primary nectar robber, the bird Diglossa baritula, on flower nectar secretion and reproductive output of two hummingbird-pollinated plant species with contrasting breeding systems. We used the hermaphroditic Salvia mexicana and the androdioecious Fuchsia microphylla. In addition, because the distinction between pollinators and robbers is not so sharp, we compared the pollination efficiencies of D. baritula and of five species of hummingbirds visiting the flowers of the same plant species. 2. Flowers of the two plant species were frequently robbed (92 and 37% of the flowers in Salvia mexicana and Fuchsia microphylla respectively). For both species, field censuses of robbed and unrobbed flowers showed no differences in fruit set. Experimentally induced nectar robbery did not affect the cumulative production of nectar in both plant species. However, in S. mexicana, but not in F. microphylla, intact flowers produced more concentrated nectar. 3. The role of D. baritula and hummingbirds on seed production per flower, was assessed by exposing individual flowers to different schedules of visitation by caged flower visitors. In S. mexicana, the number of seeds produced by flowers visited by the robber only was similar to that of flowers visited by the least efficient pollinator but lower than that of those visited by the other pollinators. 4. In F. microphylla, seed production by flowers visited by the robber only was lower than that of flowers visited by all other pollinators. 5. For both plant species visitation by the robber plus hummingbirds yielded a similar number of seeds as flowers visited by the more effective pollinator. 6. There was no field evidence that nectar robbery by D. baritula damages nectaries or ovules and, since under natural conditions flower visitation by the robber only was very rare, we conclude that for these two plant species D. baritula may be regarded as a commensal or even a low-efficiency pollinator.