The problem of germ layers in sponges (Porifera) and some issues concerning early metazoan evolution

Abstract

Nowadays the formation of germ layers (endoderm and mesoderm) is associated with gastrulation. The question of whether the cell movements during early embryonic development in sponges (Porifera) are gastrulation as in eumetazoans remains in dispute. Recent data on the histological organization, digestion and embryonic morphogenesis in sponges are analyzed here in an attempt to answer this question. Unique features of these basal Metazoa are the lack of intestinal epithelium, digestive parenchyma or any cell population specialized in digestion. Food particles are captured by cells of almost all types. These data show that sponges have no embryonic layers such as ectoderm or endoderm, characteristic to eumetazoans, and, consequently, no gastrulation. We make an assumption that the formation of germ layers cannot be considered as a recapitulation of events that took place in the common ancestor of Porifera and Eumetazoa. The unity of Metazoa is expressed not in the presence of gastrulation processes per se, but in the universal nature of cell movement mechanisms ensuring various types of morphogenesis, including those underlying gastrulation. It is concluded that metazoan mechanisms of morphogenetic movements must have emerged in the course of evolution prior to the separation of the germ layers like endoderm and ectoderm.