The Place of Energy Security in the National Security Framework: An Assessment Approach

Daniel Mara,Ganna Kharlamova,Andriy Stavytskyy,Silviu Nate

doi:10.3390/en15020658

Daniel Mara, Ganna Kharlamova + Show 2 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.3390/en15020658

Copy DOI

Abstract

The term “energy security” is used almost everywhere in economic and political discussions related to energy supply. However, different authors use different meanings to express the concept of energy security. Quite often, this term is used to give more importance or relevance to issues that are often not inherently related to energy security. Attempts to define the essence of the concept of “energy security” have hitherto not been systematic and are characterized by a variety of approaches, and some insufficient justification especially in the aspect of state national security is notable. Our contribution to the discourse development is the consideration of energy security as part of internationally recognized indices that are developed to assess the temperature of world security. A regression modeling approach to test the crucial factors of social-economic development that impact the energy security indicators is presented. The literature analysis and review of the world’s existing national security indices show that the link between energy security and national security is in fact hardly considered. Mostly, energy security is considered in the dichotomy concerning economic security at the international, as well as national levels. The calculative regression modeling revealed that the significant correlation of economic and energy security is just for the U.S.A., the rest of the analyzed countires display the weak or non-significant correlations of the indices of economic/energy/security threats. That pushes the discussion on whether energy security is indeed so impactful a factor for geo-policy and geo-economy, or whether it is mostly the well-rolled media-supported megatrend. However, the present study notes a great shortage of long-term cross-state indices to reflect energy, economic, and national security to allow for valuable modeling.

Highlights

The issue of energy security has come to the fore, in discussions at multilateral global and international regional forums
The internationalization and globalization of energy as an industry, as well as the strengthening of energy interdependence of most countries, increasingly confirms the thesis of the inability to ensure national energy security [2], which led to an understanding of the need for international energy security at regional and global levels [3]
The search reflects whether the national security indexes of the main energy players contain energy security in its calculative methodology

Summary

Introduction

The issue of energy security has come to the fore, in discussions at multilateral global and international regional forums. The internationalization and globalization of energy as an industry, as well as the strengthening of energy interdependence of most countries, increasingly confirms the thesis of the inability to ensure national energy security [2], which led to an understanding of the need for international energy security at regional and global levels [3]. The present study seeks to address the relationship between energy security, national security, and civil rights, and it considers the various dimensions of energy security that have affected civil rights based on the rights enshrined in the Charter of Civil Rights and other legal documents. The evaluation of energy security needs to consider different dimensions and is of the utmost importance as a benchmark to conceive and implement different policies.

Objectives

Methods

Results