The optimal applications of scPDSI and SPEI in characterizing meteorological drought, agricultural drought and terrestrial water availability on a global scale

Abstract

The Palmer Drought Severity Index (scPDSI) and the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) are two of the most commonly used drought indices. However, scPDSI and SPEI at a specific scale are often used interchangeably to characterize meteorological drought, agricultural drought, or terrestrial water availability, leading to potential inaccuracies in research outcomes. This study thus presents a global-scale assessment of the applications of scPDSI and SPEI at various timescales (SPEIs) in these contexts. Our findings indicate that scPDSI is more suitable for monitoring agricultural drought than meteorological drought, and highlight the effectiveness of SPEI at one month scale (SPEI01) for meteorological drought. Additionally, SPEI at nine months scale (SPEI09) is more appropriate for agricultural drought. Regarding their relationship with vegetation water stress, scPDSI and SPEI09 are more closely associated with root-zone soil moisture, while SPEI01 is most closely linked to vapor pressure deficit. Furthermore, we evaluate the capability of scPDSI and SPEI in representing terrestrial water availability by analyzing the responses of diverse vegetation indicators to them, including the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Leaf Area Index (LAI), Solar-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence (SIF), and Gross Primary Productivity (GPP). All four vegetation indicators show the highest sensitivity of negative response to SPEI01 in cold climate regions, suggesting SPEI01 is most applicable in these regions. In drylands, vegetation indicators exhibit higher sensitivity of positive responses to SPEI at six months scale (SPEI06) and SPEI09, indicating SPEI06 and SPEI09 effectively characterize water availability in such areas. These findings enhance the understanding of scPDSI and SPEI, providing clearer guidelines for their global-scale applications in meteorological drought, agricultural drought, and terrestrial water availability.