The importance of the individual in the ‘causal’ relationship between attractiveness and self‐esteem

Abstract

AbstractThis paper argues that many psychological explanations underlying health and social behaviour stress the importance of the relationship between attractiveness and self‐esteem. The nature of this relationship is not well understood, yet can have important implications for the individual in areas of medical intervention which involve treatment on aesthetic grounds. A survey of psychosocial factors among 1018 children aged 11‐12 years is reported. The study examined the association between perception of physical attractiveness and self‐esteem in order to clarify the relationship between self‐esteem and self versus others' perception of attractiveness. Self‐ratings of attractiveness were linked to judges' ratings to determine whether subjects underrated, over‐rated, or accurately perceived their own physical attractiveness. The results showed that although ratings of general facial attractiveness by others were associated with self‐perceived attractiveness, in the specific area of dental health, attractiveness (as judged by others) was not. There were no significant relationships between ratings of attractiveness by others and self‐esteem. Self‐perception of attractiveness, however, was significantly associated with self‐esteem. Further analyses showed that children who under‐rated their own facial attractiveness had a lower mean score for self‐esteem than over‐raters or accurate perceivers (who did not differ significantly). In contrast, under‐raters of dental attractiveness had a lower mean score for self‐esteem than over‐raters, but did not differ significantly from accurate perceivers. Over‐raters of dental attractiveness had a higher mean score for self‐esteem than accurate perceivers. These finding suggest that if an over‐rater were to receive treatment on aesthetic grounds it is unlikely, given that they have high self‐esteem already, that such intervention will have a profound psychological impact. These data indicate the importance of determining the way in which individuals evaluate their appearance compared to others, and may help to clarify previously equivocal findings concerning the relationship between self‐esteem and attractiveness.