The Implantable Cardioverter-Defibrillator Minimalist

Abstract

The implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) was devised to satisfy the unmet need for an effective, instantaneous therapy to prevent sudden cardiac death (SCD) due to ventricular fibrillation (VF) in at-risk, ambulatory patients. That therapy was a high-voltage electric shock delivered directly into the heart muscle. More than 3 decades later, shocks are still the defining operating characteristic of ICDs, and no other instantaneously effective therapy for VF exists. This elite status was clinched by large randomized clinical trials1,2 which demonstrated that ICDs improved mortality in patients with reduced left ventricular ejection fraction, regardless of pathogenesis or accompanying symptoms of heart failure (HF), by primary prevention of SCD due to ventricular tachyarrhythmia (VTA). Like bradycardia pacemakers for asystole, the ICD resides as a therapy genre of one, with no peer, and no competitor on the horizon. These sibling therapies for lethal heart rhythm disturbances will stand prominently among the greatest medical achievements of the 20th century. The ICD is a mature technology, and neither the technique nor the tools have changed much for several decades. Despite a certain evolutionary elegance of the operating system, the ICD is still a blunt instrument. Although it is true that some innovation has occurred, it is still a matter of a shock delivered by insulated metal conductors residing somewhere in direct proximity to the heart. No innovation beyond the fundamental of a timed shock for VF has proven to enhance mortality benefit. The basic design persists simply because no one can think of a suitable alternative and the self-satisfying aphorism that “shocks save lives.” Yet there is a growing intellectual dissatisfaction with the unintended consequences of this powerful, irreplaceable therapy. The stimulus for this self-inspection is an awareness of the very high morbidity risk overhead borne by the primary prevention patient, in particular, …