The general significance of variability in cave regressive traits for evolution

Abstract

Abstract Rudimentary structures are variable, which is most impressively demonstrated by the eyes and dark body pigmentation of species evolving in caves. As these can often still be crossed with their ancestral surface sister forms, variability is usually attributed to hybridization. For two invertebrate and two vertebrate cave species, I show here that in spite of genetic separation between surface and cave forms, variability of the rudimentary structures is nonetheless present. This probably results from the loss of stabilizing selection, because neutral deleterious mutations are no longer eliminated. In contrast, compensatory traits in caves do not differ from their surface forms with respect to variability, because both are subject to selection. In the phylogenetically young Astyanax cave populations, traits compensatory to cave life have achieved different stages of adaptation compared to the phylogenetically old populations. They may show the same degree of differentiation, be intermediate or do not differ from the surface ancestor. This is attributed to different intensities of selection.