The Fuel of Our Future: Hydrogen or Methane?

Abstract

Growing concern about climate processes has caused an interest in low-carbon fuels, such as methane and hydrogen. Although hydrogen seems to be beyond comparison in this regard, the need for high energy consumption for its production—mainly due to the same fossil hydrocarbons, low specific volume energy, and problems with its storage and transportation—make the production and consumption in the “hydrogen energy” chain extremely expensive, and even environmentally unattractive. Estimates show that it is significantly inferior to methane-based energy not only in terms of costs and efficiency, but also in terms of global CO2 emissions. The vast resources of natural methane, primarily gas hydrates, are able to provide humanity with energy and hydrocarbons for hundreds of years. Meanwhile, promising modern technologies for the conversion of methane into basic chemicals—including new autothermal technologies for its oxidative conversion into syngas and its direct conversion into chemicals—allow the consideration of methane not only as a fuel, but also as the basis of future organic chemistry. Methane and other hydrocarbons, synthesized using thermonuclear energy from CO2 and water—which are abundant on the Earth—can remain the most convenient mobile, easily stored and transported fuels and universal chemical raw materials, even after the inevitable transition to thermonuclear energy in the distant future. The inclusion of CO2 through the synthesis of methane into the global energy cycle will allow real global carbon neutrality to be achieved.