Abstract

The current Ebola epidemic provides a dramatic example of the potential of passive antibody for infectious diseases that is also instructive of the hurdles and limitations involved in wide-scale reintroduction of this powerful anti-infective strategy. Passive antibody was first used in the 1890s as therapy and was the first effective anti-infective therapy. Serum was largely discontinued with the advent of antibiotic in the early 1940s because it could not compete with regards to cost or ease of administration and had additional complexities, including that it had to be administered early in disease, it manifested lot-to-lot variation, and its efficacy required immune donors and the availability of a specific microbiological diagnosis so sera could be matched to the disease-causing microorganism [1]. Serum using heterologous sera was also associated with sickness, a syndrome caused by the formation of antigen-antibody complexes. However, antibiotic was never shown to be superior in efficacy to antibody and there were some conditions, such as pneumococcal pneumonia, where it may have had some advantages. Despite their wholesale abandonment, antibody therapies did retain a niche for certain conditions where no drugs were available, such as the prevention and/or treatment of tetanus, botulism, and certain viral diseases. The development of hybridoma technology and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) in the mid-1970s promised to solve many of the problems of serum therapy, but, to date, there has not been formal reintroduction of antibody therapies for infectious diseases despite considerable and ongoing efforts to develop such therapies against viral diseases, such as HIV infection, and bacterial diseases, such as those caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylacoccous aureus. In contrast, mAbs have revolutionized the treatment of many cancers and rheumatic diseases and dozens have been licensed. Here we analyze why Ab-based therapies remain so underdeveloped for infectious diseases through the prism of the Ebola epidemic.

Highlights

  • We will refrain from commenting on the efficacy of Ab therapies against Ebola virus and will focus, instead, on how this concurrent epidemic brings into focus the promise of this therapy while highlighting the difficulties involved in reintroducing antibodies for the therapy of infectious diseases

  • It is of interest that immunomodulation has been proposed as an intervention for Ebola virus [20] and anecdotal reports suggest that control of Ebola-virus-induced cytokine storm might be beneficial therapeutically

  • Ab-based therapies are severely underdeveloped for the treatment of infectious diseases. The causes for this are complex, we identify five factors that are, in some cases, interrelated and, yet, all work in synergy to hinder the widespread reintroduction of Ab therapies to this field

Read more

Summary

OPEN ACCESS

The current Ebola epidemic provides a dramatic example of the potential of passive antibody therapy for infectious diseases that is instructive of the hurdles and limitations involved in wide-scale reintroduction of this powerful anti-infective strategy. Antibiotic therapy was never shown to be superior in efficacy to antibody therapy and there were some conditions, such as pneumococcal pneumonia, where it may have had some advantages Despite their wholesale abandonment, antibody therapies did retain a niche for certain conditions where no drugs were available, such as the prevention and/or treatment of tetanus, botulism, and certain viral diseases. We will refrain from commenting on the efficacy of Ab therapies against Ebola virus and will focus, instead, on how this concurrent epidemic brings into focus the promise of this therapy while highlighting the difficulties involved in reintroducing antibodies for the therapy of infectious diseases

Advantages and Limitations of Ab Therapies
Underdevelopment of Ab Therapies for Infectious Diseases
The Near and Far Horizons
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call