The Dynamic Origins of Type 1 Diabetes

Abstract

Over a century ago, there was diabetes and only diabetes. Subsequently, diabetes came to be much more discretely defined (1) by age at onset (childhood or adult onset), clinical phenotype (lean or obese), treatment (insulin dependent or not insulin dependent), and, more recently, immune genotype (type 1 or type 2 diabetes). Although these categories broadly describe groups, they are often insufficient to categorize specific individuals, such as children having non–insulin-dependent diabetes and adults having type 1 diabetes (T1D) even when not requiring insulin. Indeed, ketoacidosis at presentation can be a feature of either T1D or type 2 diabetes. That heterogeneity extends to the origins and character of both major types of diabetes. In this issue of Diabetes Care , Redondo et al. (2) leverage the TrialNet study of subjects with a single diabetes-associated autoantibody at screening in order to explore factors determining progression to multiple autoantibodies and, subsequently, the pathogenesis of T1D. T1D is initiated by presumed nongenetic event(s) operating in children with potent genetic susceptibility. But there is substantial heterogeneity even within the origins of this disease. Those nongenetic events evoke different autoantibodies such that T1D patients with insulin autoantibodies (IAA) have different features from those with GAD autoantibodies (GADA) (3,4). The former, in contrast with the latter, are younger both at seroconversion and at development of clinical diabetes, the two groups having different genetic risk and those with IAA having greater insulin secretory loss (3,4) (Fig. 1). These observations hint at distinct disease-associated networks leading to T1D, perhaps induced by distinct nongenetic events. Such disease-associated pathways could operate in unison, especially in children with T1D, who often have multiple autoantibodies. Figure 1 The incidence of insulin-treated T1D in the first 35 years of life. Cases with multiple autoantibodies have different features (as illustrated) than those with …