The competitive mechanism between post-abandonment Chinese fir plantations and rehabilitated natural secondary forest species under an in situ conservation policy

Abstract

During the past 30 years, the global forest area has been subject to a continuous increase in planted forests and a decline in natural forests, raising significant concerns about biodiversity protection. Once these plantations are abandoned due to changes in conservation or forest management policies, can they recover to the same state as natural forests during secondary succession? The key ecological processes supporting the stable coexistence or competitive elimination mechanisms between post-abandonment plantations and natural secondary forest tree species are still poorly understood and may be the decisive ecological processes driving secondary forest restoration. A 12-ha long-term forest plot was established in an abandoned Chinese fir plantation that has been protected under an in situ protection policy for 40 years. In total, 66,317 individual trees were stem mapped and identified at the species level, and the spatial survival strategies and species coexistence mechanisms between Chinese fir and natural secondary forest tree species were investigated. The results showed that the spatial survival strategy of Chinese fir could effectively trade off a high conspecific density-dependent mortality rate of individuals during the early stage of secondary succession for the long-term survival of the whole population, which promoted its dominance during later stages of succession. By contrast, although the higher survival rate and larger intraspecific aggregation scale of natural secondary forest individuals favored their survival during initial colonization, this spatial survival strategy might occur at the cost of neglecting suitable habitats and the loss of competitive advantages at the later stage of succession. Regarding interspecific competition, the asymmetric competition process further ensured the advantages of Chinese fir in individual size growth and increased the competitive advantage of Chinese fir over natural secondary forest tree species by exclusion through interspecific competition during the later secondary succession stage. Our results suggest that implementing a forest recovery program or an in situ protection policy based on post-abandonment monoculture plantations may involve great uncertainty about whether the goal can be achieved. Specifically, although this strategy could quickly increase forest coverage and restore the forest landscape, it may also create difficulties in restoring the forest to its original state.