The Broken Promise of Institutional Psychiatry: Sexuality, Women and Mental Illness in 1950s Lebanon

Abstract

This article traces the case of Hala, a woman chronic patient of the Lebanon Hospital for Mental and Nervous Disorders (LHMND) in late 1950s Lebanon. Her story reveals a conglomeration of actors, expertise and technologies that regulated both her sexuality and mental illness, as she was moved, returned, then moved again, from the care of the family to the care of the psychiatric institution. By reconstructing an ethnographic case of the story of Hala, the article tackles an under-investigated area of research at the intersection of subjectivity, sexuality, psychiatry and family life. The case of Hala illustrates an on-going tension in defining and diagnosing mental illness for women between two forms of care: institutional psychiatry on one hand—promising a quick return of patients to society—and the family on the other, with its own understandings of what constitutes abnormality for women. Having lived at the hospital for more than twenty years, Hala’s voice and experience provide a powerful contribution to the ethnographic history of psychiatry in Lebanon. The article tackles questions on competing psychiatric and social authorities and the formation of psychiatric subjectivities. It also provides methodological and ethical reflections on the use of archives when conducting ethnographic research on psychiatry from the global peripheries. The case of Hala illustrates the patient’s own experience of LHMND’s policies of social rehabilitation in the late 1950s. It adds to a broader understanding of the processes that have led to the pathologizing of sexuality in under-studied societies such as Lebanon and the Middle East.