Targeting the protein folding transition state by mutation: Large scale (un)folding rate accelerations without altering native stability.

Abstract

Proteins are constantly undergoing folding and unfolding transitions, with rates that determine their homeostasis in vivo and modulate their biological function. The ability to optimize these rates without affecting overall native stability is hence highly desirable for protein engineering and design. The great challenge is, however, that mutations generally affect folding and unfolding rates with inversely complementary fractions of the net free energy change they inflict on the native state. Here we address this challenge by targeting the folding transition state (FTS) of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2), a very slow and stable two-state folding protein with an FTS known to be refractory to change by mutation. We first discovered that the CI2's FTS is energetically taxed by the desolvation of several, highly conserved, charges that form a buried salt bridge network in the native structure. Based on these findings, we designed a CI2 variant that bears just four mutations and aims to selectively stabilize the FTS. This variant has >250-fold faster rates in both directions and hence identical native stability, demonstrating the success of our FTS-centric design strategy. With an optimized FTS, CI2 also becomes 250-fold more sensitive to proteolytic degradation by its natural substrate chymotrypsin, and completely loses its activity as inhibitor. These results indicate that CI2 has been selected through evolution to have a very unstable FTS in order to attain the kinetic stability needed to effectively function as protease inhibitor. Moreover, the CI2 case showcases that protein (un)folding rates can critically pivot around a few key residues-interactions, which can strongly modify the general effects of known structural factors such as domain size and fold topology. From a practical standpoint, our results suggest that future efforts should perhaps focus on identifying such critical residues-interactions in proteins as best strategy to significantly improve our ability to predict and engineer protein (un)folding rates.