Subsurface Archaea associated with rapid geobiological change in a model Yellowstone hot spring

Abstract

Despite over a century of study, it is unknown if continental hydrothermal fields support high-temperature subsurface biospheres. Cinder Pool is among the deepest hot springs in Yellowstone and is widely studied due to unique sulfur geochemistry that is attributed to hydrolysis of molten elemental sulfur at ∼18 m depth that promotes several chemical reactions that maintain low sulfide, low oxygen, and a moderate pH of ∼4.0. Following ∼100 years of stability, Cinder Pool underwent extreme visual and chemical change (acidification) in 2018. Here, we show that depth-resolved geochemical and metagenomic-based microbial community analyses pre- (2016) and post-acidification (2020) indicate the changes are likely attributable to feedbacks between geological/geochemical processes, sulfur oxidation by subsurface Sulfolobales Archaea, and the disappearance of molten sulfur at depth. These findings underscore the dynamic and rapid feedback between the geosphere and biosphere in continental hydrothermal fields and suggest subsurface biospheres to be more prevalent in these systems than previously recognized.