Structured representations in a quantum probability model of similarity

Abstract

Recently, Busemeyer et al. (2011) presented a model for how the conjunction fallacy (Tversky & Kahneman, 1983) emerges, based on the principles of quantum probability (QP) theory. Pothos et al. (2013) extended this model to account for the main similarity findings of Tversky (1977), which have served as a golden standard for testing novel theories of similarity. However, Tversky’s (1977) empirical findings did not address the now established insight that, in comparing two objects, overlap in matching parts of the objects tends to have a greater impact on their similarity, than overlap in non-matching parts. We show how the QP similarity model can be directly extended to accommodate structure in similarity comparisons. Smolensky’s et al.’s (2014) proposal for modeling structure in linguistic representations, with tensor products, can be adapted ‘as is’ with the QP similarity model. The formal properties of the extended QP similarity model are analyzed, some indicative fits are presented, and, finally, a novel prediction is developed.