Statistical Hierarchy of Varying Speed of Light Cosmologies

Abstract

Abstract Many varying speed of light (VSL) theories have been developed recently. Here we address the issue of their observational verification in a fully comprehensive way. By using the most updated cosmological probes, we test three different candidates for a VSL theory (Barrow & Magueijo, Avelino & Martins, and Moffat). We consider many different Ansätze for both the functional form of c(z) and the dark energy dynamics. We compare these results using a reliable statistical tool such as the Bayesian evidence. We find that the present cosmological data are perfectly compatible with any of these VSL scenarios, but for the Moffat model there is a higher Bayesian evidence ratio in favor of VSL rather than the c = constant ΛCDM scenario. Moreover, in such a scenario, the VSL signal can help to strengthen constraints on the spatial curvature (with indication toward an open universe), to clarify some properties of dark energy (exclusion of a cosmological constant at level), and is also falsifiable in the near future owing to peculiar issues that differentiate this model from the standard one. Finally, we apply an information prior and entropy prior in order to put physical constraints on the models, though still in favor Moffat’s proposal.