Stability of the coronal magnetic field around large confined and eruptive solar flares

Abstract

The coronal magnetic field, which overlies the current-carrying field of solar active regions, straps the magnetic configuration below. The characteristics of this overlying field are crucial in determining if a flare will be eruptive and accompanied by a coronal mass ejection (CME), or if it will remain confined without a CME. In order to improve our understanding of the pre-requisites of eruptive solar flares we study and compare different measures that characterize the eruptive potential of solar active regions --- the critical height of the torus instability (TI) as a local measure and the helicity ratio as a global measure --- with the structural properties of the underlying magnetic field namely the altitude of the center of the current-carrying magnetic structure. Using time series of 3D optimization-based nonlinear force-free magnetic field models of ten different active regions (ARs) around the time of large solar flares, we determined the altitudes of the current-weighted centers of the non-potential model structures. Based on the potential magnetic field, we inspected the decay index, $n$, in multiple vertical planes oriented alongside or perpendicular to the flare-relevant polarity inversion line, and estimated the critical height (hc ) of TI using different thresholds of $n$. The critical heights were interpreted with respect to the altitudes of the current-weighted centers of the associated non-potential structures as well as the eruptive character of the associated flares, and the eruptive potential of the host AR as characterized by the helicity ratio. Our most important findings are that (i) hc is more segregated in terms of the flare type than the helicity ratio, and (ii) coronal field configurations with a higher eruptive potential (in terms of the helicity ratio) also appear to be more prone to TI. Furthermore, we find no pronounced differences in the altitudes of the non-potential structures prior to confined and eruptive flares. An aspect that requires further investigation is that, generally, the modeled non-potential structures do not really reside in a torus-instable regime, so the applicability of the chosen nonlinear force-free modeling approach when targeting the structural properties of the coronal magnetic field is unclear.