Southern Ocean Surface Temperatures and Cloud Biases in Climate Models Connected to the Representation of Glacial Deep Ocean Circulation

Abstract

Abstract Simulating and reproducing the past Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC) with comprehensive climate models are essential to understanding past climate changes as well as to testing the ability of the models in simulating different climates. At the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), reconstructions show a shoaling of the AMOC compared to modern climate. However, almost all state-of-the-art climate models simulate a deeper LGM AMOC. Here, it is shown that this paleodata–model discrepancy is partly related to the climate model biases in modern sea surface temperatures (SST) over the Southern Ocean (70°–45°S). Analysis of model outputs from three phases of the Paleoclimate Model Intercomparison Project shows that models with warm Southern Ocean SST biases tend to simulate a deepening of the LGM AMOC, while the opposite is observed in models with cold SST biases. As a result, a positive correlation of 0.41 is found between SST biases and LGM AMOC depth anomalies. Using sensitivity experiments with a climate model, we show, as an example, that changes in parameters associated with the fraction of cloud thermodynamic phase in a climate model reduce the biases in the warm SST over the modern Southern Ocean. The less biased versions of the model then reproduce a colder Southern Ocean at the LGM, which increases formation of Antarctic Bottom Water and causes shoaling of the LGM AMOC, without affecting the LGM climate in other regions. The results highlight the importance of sea surface conditions and clouds over the Southern Ocean in simulating past and future global climates. Significance Statement To test the ability of comprehensive climate models, simulations of the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) have been conducted. However, most models simulated a deeper Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC) in the LGM, which contradicts paleodata suggesting a shallower AMOC. Here, using multimodel analysis and sensitivity experiments with a climate model, we show that this paleodata–model discrepancy is partly related to model biases in the modern Southern Ocean. Improvements in Southern Ocean surface temperatures and clouds reproduce a colder climate over the Southern Ocean at the LGM, which causes an intense shoaling of the AMOC due to increased formation of Antarctic Bottom Water. These results demonstrate the important effect of model biases over the Southern Ocean on simulating past climates.